Reactiviteit op de omgeving. De invloed van stress en beloning op neurochemie, affect en gedrag in het psychose continuum
Year: 2016
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Our goal in any given environment is to gain rewards, avoid losses, and mitigate stressors. In fact, successful pursuit of our desires despite the pressures of the everyday life is an essential marker of mental health. Conversely, reduced capacity to cope with stressors and engage in motivated behavior is the hallmark of severe psychiatric diagnoses, most notably the psychotic disorder. This dissertation explores the many facets of the healthy as well as compromised environmental reactivity in relation to the symptomatology of psychosis. The first section, On reward, elucidates mechanisms of reward sensitivity, the second section termed On stress focuses on stress responsiveness, and the last section, On stress and reward, ties both phenomena together by exploring the effect of stress on the capacity to experience reward as such. Chapter 1 introduces the current state-of-the-art in research into reactivity to stress and reward in healthy state and psychosis. Reward capacity is typically tested using computerized tasks in which incentives are used to guide behavior, while stress is experimentally induced using social evaluation and exclusion. This way, both reward and stress processing is shown to engage the striatal and prefrontal regions of the brain, and thought to depend on dopamine signaling. Individuals with psychosis demonstrate robust insensitivity to rewards linked to severe motivational impairments, in the presence of hypersensitivity to stress accompanied by psychotic symptoms. There are critical gaps in our understanding of the neurochemical, behavioral and affective correlates of this abnormality, precluding the design of rational interventions. On reward Chapter 2 presents an account of neurochemical modulation of reward processing in the striatal and limbic areas of the brain in individuals with a familial predisposition to psychosis (healthy first-degree relatives of patients) and healthy controls. Positron emission tomography with the ligand 18F-fallypride indexing dopaminergic transmission detected unaltered reward-induced dopamine activity in the predisposed group, possibly conferring resilience to the disorder. Additionally, this study revealed that greater extent of dopamine activity during reward processing in the most of striatum is associated with better performance on the reward task, highlighting the specific role of the striatum in reward-oriented behavior, and preservation of this specificity in individuals predisposed to psychosis. Chapter 3 investigates behavioral reactivity to rewards and reveals that patients with the most severe symptoms of psychosis adopt, paradoxically, the most advantageous strategy in a reward task. Upon closer look, however, this behavior appears to represent perseveration and inflexibility rather than true supra-normal reward sensitivity, also reflected in the clinical profile of pronounced motivational impairments in this group of patients. Chapter 4 presents the link between reward deficits and avolition by identifying affective experience of reward as the driving force of motivated action in the everyday life. The experience sampling method applied to a substantial sample of healthy participants reveals that positive affect experienced while performing an activity significantly increases the odds of engaging in that activity in the near future, thus identifying optimal reward sensitivity as the imperative prerequisite of the propagation of reward-oriented behavior. Translated to psychosis, attenuated responsiveness to rewards demonstrated by the patients could potentially hinder goal-oriented behavior in their daily lives. On stress Chapter 5 provides an account of significant stress-induced dopamine activity in the prefrontal and temporal cortices of patients with a psychotic disorder and healthy controls. Positron emission tomography imaging detected intact magnitude and spatial extent of cortical dopaminergic activity under acute stress in patients with chronic psychotic disorders. Moreover, the functional relevance of cortical dopamine in stress modulation was confirmed by showing significant positive associations between stress-induced DA activity and subjective stress experience in both groups of participants. Large body of literature suggests that early life stress, childhood trauma, can “inoculate” the dopaminergic systems to better endure stress later in life, and that this process might be absent in psychosis due to the noxious effect of both childhood trauma and current stress in this group. Chapter 6 therefore investigates the effect of childhood trauma on stress-related DA activity in the adulthood in the existing data from chapter 5. In the healthy controls, more severe childhood trauma is associated with more extensive dopamine activity under stress in the medial prefrontal cortex, hinting at a mechanism of adaptive calibration of the prefrontal dopamine signaling of stress. No such relationship was observed in patients with chronic psychosis, however, suggesting a deviation from this adaptive pattern in this group. Chapter 7 further explores areas of the brain that are involved in the modulation of negative affective experiences such as fear and pain, important constituents of the stress response. The cerebellum has reliably been implicated in learning and memory, and increasingly recognized for its role in fear conditioning. This chapter presents the activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis that pooled all existing functional neuroimaging studies of fear conditioning in healthy participants, and identified four loci of cerebellar activation during the acquisition of fear, warranting further exploration of stress processing in this region. On stress and reward Chapter 8 operates on the assumption that in real world, rewards are always encountered against the background of a variable degree of stress, and tests the premise that stress affects the experience of reward. Indeed, both in the laboratory and in the daily-life stress was found to have a negative impact on reward capacity of healthy individuals, with a potential to trigger the severe reward deficits seen in psychosis. Chapter 9 summarizes the findings of the human normative reactivity to stress and reward, and the deviations, or the lack thereof, in individuals on the spectrum of psychosis. Patients demonstrated largely intact dopaminergic reactivity to stress, and their relatives showed intact reward-related dopamine activity. Only when childhood trauma was considered, and reward deficit was tested behaviorally, meaningful differences between healthy controls and those further on the spectrum of psychosis emerged. Contrastingly, in healthy controls the exposure to positive and negative environmental factors was found to have a decisive impact on reward capacity and behavior. One is thus compelled to wonder whether psychosis might be the results of a vicious cycle of environmental adversities, with the brain at its center doing precisely what it evolved to do - interacting.
Source: Lirias (KU Leuven)
Author: Kasanova, Zuzana
Institutions: Maastricht University, KU Leuven
Language: English
Subfield: Cellular and Molecular Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7014779634
