Work

The Adrenal Vein sampling International Study (AVIS): main results of phase 1 and 2 of the study \n

Year: 2014
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Context. Primary aldosteronism (PA) is the most common form of secondary endocrine hypertension. To make a distinction between surgically-curable and surgically-non curable causes, the Endocrine Society guidelines recommend the use of adrenal venous sampling (AVS), which is considered invasive, technically challenging, difficult to interpret, and commonly held to be risky. However, whether and how these guidelines are interpreted in clinical practice is still unknown. Hence, the purpose of this PhD work was to set up a study, the Adrenal Vein sampling International Study (AVIS), to answer several questions concerning AVS. \nDesign and settings. AVIS is an observational, retrospective, multicenter international study. The eligible centers were identified among those that had published data about PA and/or AVS into English scientific literature during the period between 2005 and 2010. The study is designed in two phases, the first one is aimed to collect the data on AVS while the second one, the data on single patients. \nObjective. In the first phase of the study, the main outcomes were to determine the complication rate of AVS and the ways in which it is performed and interpreted at major referral centers. Specifically, the rate of PA patients in whom AVS is performed and the number of AVS studies performed yearly between 2005 and 2010 per each center; the number of radiologists that perform AVS at each center and the rate of complication; the use of bilaterally simultaneous or sequential AVS catheterization and the use of cosyntropin stimulation during AVS; the use of AVS studies not bilaterally selective for diagnosis; the interpretation of AVS results by calculation of the selectivity, lateralization and contralateral suppression index and minimum cutoff value used; the cost of AVS for the National Health System/Insurance and for patients. \nThe second phase is aimed to collect individual patients data to assess the rate of bilaterally selective AVS studies as a function of the different cutoff values of the selectivity index; to identify the best cutoff value for the identification of the lateralized aldosterone excess; to clarify if contralateral suppression allows diagnosing lateralization when only unilateral (usually left-sided) AVS is successful; to assess the rate of the patients with lateralized aldosterone excess secretion cured by adrenalectomy; to establish whether medical therapy induces improvement of high blood pressure (BP) in PA subtypes characterized by bilateral aldosterone excess secretion; assess the rate of AVS concordant /discordant with results of imaging tests. For reasons of time and brevity in this preliminary analysis the data on contralateral suppression will not be included. \nResults. Phase 1: Twenty out of 24 eligible centers from Europe, Asia, Australia and North America participated and provided information on 2604 AVS studies performed between 2005 and 2010. The percentage of PA patients systematically submitted to AVS was 77% (median, range: 19%-100%). The overall rate of adrenal vein rupture was 0.61% and it correlated directly with the number of AVS performed at a particular center (p=0.002) and inversely with the number of AVS performed by each radiologist (p=0.007). The total number of radiologists who performed AVS at the 20 centers was 51 (range, 1 to 7; median,2). Thirteen of the 20 centers used sequential and 7 bilaterally simultaneous catheterization; cosyntropin stimulation was used in 11 centers. No significant correlation has been found between the use of ACTH stimulation and sequential catheterization. \nThe cutoff values for selectivity and lateralization indices varied markedly among those centers that systematically used them. Selectivity index (SI) results to be calculated in 90% of the centers, and the cut off values varied under non-stimulated condition from 1.1 to 3, and under stimulate conditions between 2 and 10. Lateralization index (LI) is used in 95% of the centers and its cut off values varied under non-stimulated condition from 2 to 5, and under stimulate conditions between 2 and 4. Contralateral suppression index (CSI) was calculated in 65% of the centers and its cut off values varied under non-stimulated condition from 0.5 to 1, and under stimulate conditions between 0.9 and 1. \nIt was found out that 60% of centers used unilaterally selective studies when bilateral results were unavailable for the diagnosis and there was significant correlation between use of unilateral selective AVS and contralateral suppression (p=0,05). In contrast, no significant correlation was found between the use of ACTH stimulation and contralateral suppression. The costs of AVS showed a wide variability among centers and countries, both for the patient and for the insurance or national health care system. The cost ranged from 80 (€) to 10,532 € for health insurance systems and from 0 to 1,357 € for the patient. \nPhase 2: Due to the delay of some centers in providing the data, we performed a preliminary analysis only with the available data. We collected information on 1.030 PA patients who underwent AVS in 13 referral centers worldwide. Resistant hypertension was found in 43% of the patients, 59% were men; the majority were Caucasians. \nThe analysis of overall improvement at follow up of high BP with either pharmacological or surgical treatment evidenced 19% of patients with cured high BP, 49% of patients with a markedly improved BP control, 25% with only a mild improvement of BP and 8% with no improvement of BP. The analysis evidenced that women, Caucasian and African had better outcomes. \nAs regards the outcome of BP in the adrenalectomized patients, BP was cured in 34% of cases, markedly improved in 45% of patients, mildly improved in 16% of patients and no improvement in 5% of the patients. Moreover, the rate of patients who underwent adrenalectomy was lower than expected (median 53%) with a high variability among centers. The analysis evidenced that in the patients with bilateral aldosterone excess no cases showed cured o markedly improved control of high BP while on pharmacological treatment. At follow up, the majority of the patients (about 75%) showed only a mildly improved control of BP, and 24% of the patients had no improvement. \nThe analysis of the rate of bilaterally selective AVS studies as a function of different cutoff values showed that lower SI cutoff values were associated with a higher rate of bilaterally selective studies. To evaluate the best cutoff value for identifying a lateralized aldosterone excess we examined the bilaterally selective studies (by different SI cutoffs), the performance of the different LI used across the centers using as reference index cure or marked improvement of BP at follow up after the adrenalectomy. This evidenced that, at each SI, the higher the LI cutoff the higher the rate of patients who were cured or markedly improved as far as BP control. \nAs regards the rate of concordance/discordance between AVS results and CT imaging results for the diagnosis of lateralized aldosterone excess, we performed the analysis in patients with bilaterally selective AVS, with evidence of lateralized aldosterone excess, who undergo to adrenalectomy and at follow up presented cured o markedly improved BP. This analysis evidence that in this subgroup of patients the rate of concordance between AVS results and CT imaging results was low, 65% on the left side and 57% on the right side. \n Conclusions. Despite the high prevalence of PA, and the fact that AVS is crucial for discriminating between its two major subtypes, and therefore for selecting the most appropriate treatment, this study documented marked dissimilarities in the percentage of use, protocols, interpretation and cost of AVS even among the major referral centers around the world. Importantly, overall the rate of major complications was minimal, 0.61%, which demonstrates that although being generally regarded as a risky procedure, AVS is in truth safe in experienced hands. This observation therefore supports the Endocrine Society recommendation that AVS should be used in all patients with confirmed PA who are candidate for adrenalectomy and seek surgical cure. \nIn the second phase of the study, analysis of the individual patients data, evidence that a choice of more restrictive values of the selectivity and the lateralization index, translates to increased rates of cured and markedly improved BP at follow up, but this at the price of the exclusion of a greater number of patients from adrenalectomy. \n
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7017092220
FWCI:
Cites: 115
Cited by:
Related to: 10