Work

Collaboration matters - A retrospective of three user-centred building projects at Aalto University

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: User involvement in its varied forms is becoming a reality in many building projects. The year 2020 marks a rise of service design in the context of building planning in Finland as new guidelines in the building and real estate industries were introduced by a respected Building Information group. Service design is used as an umbrella term for various participatory and observatory methods in the guideline. However, this approach does evoke important questions concerning the different modes of working and objectives of user involvement throughout the planning process in architecture and building. \n \nThe purpose of this study is to clarify how to involve users and the various design objectives considered throughout the planning process in architecture and building. This study examines these processes within multiple case studies. Three building planning projects done in Aalto University are selected to situate the theory within the practice and to elucidate the complex phenomenon of user-centred planning. This thesis approached the topic by using qualitative research and investigated collaborative actions using both documentary research and semi-structured interviews (n=10). Furthermore, the collaborative design is analysed using both thematic and visual design methods based on the rich data gathered. \n \nTwo main results are identified based on the analysis. Firstly, the study creates an overview of a profoundly human-centred planning process combining the findings from the case studies and the insights from the literature review. In this process, three primary levels of action with clear phases for collaboration and diverse objectives for the use of design were revealed. Secondly, the theoretical part of this thesis addresses four stages of the collaborative process, including the following three main user-centred modes of working which are: (1) no-direct-participation with emphases on user investigation and inspiration; (2) participation with emphases on democratic and communicative acts; and (3) collaboration with emphases on collective creativity and shared expertise. This study revealed that a successful user-centred planning process calls for expertise in the strategic use of collaborative modes of working. \n \nThe results presented here may facilitate improvements in strategic method selection in building planning in general and particularly in the early collaborations for shared vision making. Based on this study, multiple future research areas for design are identified. Strategic method selection for collaborative project planning, shared vision and sensemaking at the beginning of architectural planning, as well as the connection of service design with workplace design, are all areas to be further examined in the future.
Language: English
Subfield: Architecture
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7017966269
Cites: 54
Cited by:
Related to: 10