“Days of vengeance, days of mercy”: experiencing violence and divine providence in British North America, 1744–1757
Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis addresses the ways a group of clergymen and lay people in colonial British North America used "providentialism," or the effort to explain the divine meaning behind worldly events, as a means of understanding their experience of war during King George's War (1744-1748) and the early stages of the French and Indian War (1754-1757).Rather than surveying the tremendous number and range of providential interpretations coming from pulpits throughout the Atlantic world, I closely follow the interconnected lives of members of the personal network of Jonathan Edwards, a key theologian and preacher of the Great Awakening, detailing how they perceived and responded to providence during times of violence, and how they interacted with and affected each other through a shared providentialism.Edwards's network included evangelical ministers in New England and throughout the British Atlantic; family members, including his daughter Esther Edwards Burr and her husband Aaron Burr; government and military officials like Governor William Shirley and Colonel Israel Williams of the Massachusetts colony; and the lay members of his congregations, most notably Seth and Mary Pomeroy of Northampton.In reconstructing this personal network of religious people, lay and ordained, through their letters, diaries, and sermons, I situate personal connections and providential beliefs and practices within the existing religious, political, and social milieu.While social class, educational attainment, and gender all affected the manner in which my subjects constructed or drew on providential themes, their shared religious culture and the collectivelyexperienced events of war created the space and means for them to find meaning in the violence that surrounded them.association.These patterns of military providentialism first appeared among the Edwards network during King George's War (1744-1748), when the War of the Austrian Succession in Europe pushed out into North America, and British and French forces and their native allies vied for geopolitical and economic control of the continent.Here, as will be described in Chapter 1, the core of Edwards's network was populated by the leaders of the Concert of Prayer, a transatlantic evangelical movement, including Scottish divines William McCulloch, John Erskine, and John MacLaurin, as well as Thomas Prince of Boston.When the violence resumed between England and France in North America with the French and Indian War (1754-1766) a decade later, addressed in Chapter 2, Edwards's wartime network became far more familial, and prominently featured Aaron and Esther Edwards Burr and Esther's dear friend Sarah Prince.Beyond these core networks connected by blood, marriage, friendship, and faith, these evangelicals maintained personal and working relationships with the lay congregants in the towns of Northampton, Stockbridge, and Newark, New Jersey, as well as leading government officials, including provincial governors-William Shirley and Jonathan Belcher-and military officers like Colonels Israel Williams and William Johnson.Although the composition and structure of the networks described here are doubtless a product of available sources, I believe the fact that providential wartime discourse shifted from a clerical community to a family accurately reflects real changes in these evangelicals' experiences.First, it demonstrates Jonathan Edwards's turn inward during the interwar years, as his frustrations with lay spirituality and local conflict led to his dismissal from the Northampton pastorate.It also highlights the shifting beliefs, perceptions, hopes, and fears among this broader network during the last two Anglo-French wars in North America.In reconstructing this personal network of early 19 Similarly, French Catholic clergymen in Europe and North America also understood the Anglo-French Wars as a religious conflict in providential terms and with apocalyptic consequences.British Protestants and French Catholics each saw themselves as the champions of God's true church in this struggle, and deployed many of the same ideas, rhetoric, and tropes.For more on these comparisons, see Nicole Marie Penn, "Apocalypse Now: War and Religion in Late Colonial and Early Republic America," (MA thesis, College of William and Mary, 2016), http://doi.org/10.21220/S2FW2T.20
Author: Loganbill, Alec Taylor
Institution: Kansas State University
Language: English
Subfield: History
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7018176323
