indicadores biopsicológicos para explicar a fragilidade física e a mediação do exercício nos indicadores do bem-estar psicológico, parâmetros hormonas e imunitários em mulheres idosas fisicamente frágeis
Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Frailty syndrome is a complex aging expression determined by ontogenetic and phylogenetic factors. Chronic stress has been shown to have immunosuppressive effects, to accelerate immunosenescence and to cause cumulative disorders in many physiological systems, resulting in a frail state. In a recent approach, Linda Fried and colleagues have developed a construct whose bases are muscle loss, negative energy balance and physical inactivity, called ‘Frailty Cycle’. They identified five dimensions in the construct: weakness, low resistance to an effort, slowness, low physical activity, and weight loss, which were operationalized on five criteria to identify the Physical Frailty (PF), and divide the population in frail, pre-frail and non-frail. Recently, epidemiological studies reported that cognitive impairments, low immune expression, and others global health dimensions have a powerful association with physical frailty. However, there is a need for the search for new correlated markers for the frail condition, for a better understanding of the phenomenon. On the other hand, exercise has been shown as a co-adjuvant treatment to have positive effects on several factors linked to physical frailty (e.g. improve immunity and prevent chronic diseases), because of it’s potential effect on hormonal mediation. Looking at Fried PF Phenotype construct, their dimensions share biological ‘commonalities’ that can be explained by studying the biopsychological mechanisms with exercise being a key factor in the study of these relationships. The current research was designed to investigate and characterize the prevalence of the PF in a cross-sectional Portuguese samples (institutionalized participants), to examine the relationship between PF and each one of the general health status domain such as physical fitness and functioning status; neuroendocrine and immune parameters; psychological and cognitive ability of these populations; and to verified the impact of different types of exercise in each domain of general health status. However, this doctoral thesis is presented in the form of articles, divided into five sections and their respective chapters. In total, 3 preliminary studies (2 systematic reviews of studies 1 and 2 and one exercise-intervention pilot study 3), 5 cross-sectional studies (4,5,6,7, and 8) and 3 intervention studies (9,10 and 11) were completed. The cross-sectional design consisted of the assessment of 140 older women (≥75 years old), living in different centres of heath care and social support, located in the city of Coimbra, Portugal. The participants were selected using a non-probabilistic convenience sampling based on the geographical area of the center region of Coimbra city. The experimental design characterizes as a naturalist controlled trial exercise-based intervention study with two different chair-based exercise programs. In the preliminary study 3, the group of 20 participants was submitted to 14 weeks of chair-based yoga type flexibility exercises. The control group consisted of 15 participants. The subsequent phase was designed to assess the effect of muscle-strength with elastic band exercises (n = 24) and multimodal exercise (n = 18) interventions on biopsychological outcomes in frail and pre-frail individuals. Participants in these groups attended a 45 minutes’ exercise session, two-three times per week over 24 weeks. All participants were evaluated in the pre- and post intervention moments. In this phase, the participants were extracted by PF protocol from the cross-sectional study design. Several interesting findings from different studies were found. Firstly, preliminary metanalysis review of study 01, exposed a strong association between the decline in the cognitive profile and PF, which presents a similar pattern in countries of several regions in the world (global effect size = 95%CI: 0.50-0.62, p<0.001). The systematic review of reviews (study 2) has confirmed that there was concrete evidence of a promising effect of the multimodal exercise with a long-term duration (more than five months) and a weekly frequency that varies between 3-5 times per week seems to have a superior effect to other types of exercise in improving different global health variables, attenuating and reversing the PF. In yoga intervention of study 3, it was possible to verify that chair-based exercise, being a method integrated with the conventional exercise programs of group classes, also promotes promising results in the modulation of functional fitness and salivary stress hormones indicators. However, it was clear that exercises of light intensity have little impact on these variables. The cross-sectional studies presented important evidence regarding the identification of new correlates of PF, as well as the power of some of these variables to explain the variance associated with frailty status in the institutionalized older women. Study 4 demonstrated that only aerobic resistance (AUC = sensitivity [93-96%]; specificity [74-77%], p=0.001) and cognition (AUC = sensitivity [77-88%]; specificity [65-71%], p<0.001) were the variables that had the greatest strong power of explanation of the PF status when compared to several other global health markers. Study 5 demonstrated that the agility-dynamic balance test can be used as a simple and fast tool for the detection of physical frailty (AUC=.82, 95% CI [0.74, 0.90]). Study 6 revealed clearly that low activity levels and slow gait speed were independent dimensions of PF that contribute to functional disability (p < 0.05). Central results from study 7 revealed that attitudes towards ageing and the subjective perception of happiness, explaining 34% and 40% of the variance respectively, were highlighted as new psychological dimensions that may explain the variance associated with PF. In study 8 the results pointed to salivary -amylase (AUC = 0.613, AUC 95%CI = [0.518; 0.707]) as a promising marker for prognosis of PF condition. Intervention studies with different types of multimodal (CME) and muscle strength elastic bands exercise (CSE) presented some important results. In study 9 it was possible to verify the positive effect of exercise modulation on the independent components of PF in several domains of physical function, namely in the reduction of the subjective perception of the risk of falls and in the proficiency to perform daily life activities (p < 0.05), showing a small increase in sex hormones such as DHEA and testosterone. Study 10 demonstrated the effect of exercise on the positive mediation of immune markers, specifically in the balance of the IL-10 / TNF- ratio (p < 0.05). Study 11 showed the effect of exercise on the maintenance and improvement of psychological well-being and cognitive abilities of exercise practitioners, as well as the effect of exercise on the modulation of biological stress markers (COR and -amylase) and immune function of IgA (p < 0.05). Overall, we believe that this multidimensional approach offers a more comprehensive understanding of the causes and consequences of PF status. The results help us to make some essential assumptions. In this sample, we verified the presence of new phenotypes associated with to physical frailty status: Disability of Frailty, Cognitive Frailty, Psychological Frailty, the Poor functional fitness of Frailty and Neuroendocrine-immune of Frailty. Looking at the interconnection between studies, we can see that it makes sense that frail individuals have lower physical fitness, accompanied by a physical inability to perform daily tasks and a high fear of falling. An interconnection between the low profile of psychological and cognitive state and a lower functional fitness, since the literature points out a relationship between a good functioning of the executive function and a greater capacity to solve physical tasks and daily problems, also including the management of the stress, was also found. Finally, the relationship between the unsatisfactory hormonal balance and the poor functioning of the skeletal muscle system was also seen. On the other hand, exercise intervention proved that chair-based exercise was an appropriate method to integrate with the conventional methods of exercise prescription to be used in the older-frail individuals. The impact of different exercise programs (multimodal and muscle strength exercise) showed similar findings in the several indicators. Despite the different results presented in the intervention studies, we can speculate that exercise change positively the levels of physical activity and physical fitness, which may be related to an improvement in subjective perception of fear of falling and proficiency in daily activities. The improvement of the physical performance seems to have influenced attitudes toward ageing, global self-esteem and general self-efficacy, corroborating the previous findings that already had exposed correlations between physiological well-being and some physical-functional fitness components. Although not directly assessed the social interaction component promoted by both exercise programs, this ‘parallel-effect’ may have exercised a positive influence on the improvement of emotional well-being and mood status of participants, since controls did not show similar results. For the future interventions and based on our cross-sectional studies as a pilot trial, we can recommend extending this type of study to older populations of different settings (e.g. hospitalization, community, social vulnerability). In addition, a longitudinal design that focuses on the study of the life course, starting at age 40 and above (middle-age) may produce clues about how the physical Frailty phenotype develops across the time. This was the main recommendation from the World Health Organization Scientific Committee on the International Conference on Frailty and Sarcopenia 2017, Barcelona. Exercise as an adjuvant treatment may be combined with other therapies (i.e., dietary sup
Author: Furtado, Guilherme Eustáquio
Language: Portuguese
Topic: Frailty in Older Adults
Subfield: Geriatrics and Gerontology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7019896471
