One-Stop Shop: Leveraging perceptual and cognitive confidence behaviors to characterize metacognition and its neural basis
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation introduces a novel framework for conceptualizing and measuring metacognitive ability through the lens of metacognitive stability, a construct derived from within-individual consistency across a range of narrowly defined, performance-dependent confidence behaviors. Unlike traditional approaches that assess metacognitive sensitivity or bias in isolation, our work characterizes individualized behavioral fingerprints—metacognitive behavioral profiles (BPs)—generated through cross-condition comparisons of confidence judgments under conditions that systematically dissociate confidence from performance via the Positive Evidence (PE) bias.We present a standardized online task library of four 3-alternative forced choice (3AFC) behavioral paradigms—two perceptual and two cognitive/value-based—that produce trial-wise Type 1 (performance) and Type 2 (confidence) data across 14 matched conditions. These tools enable the fine-grained quantification of metacognitive BPs using a custom analytical framework inspired by the Relative Psychometric Function (RPF). Our RPF-adjacent analysis captures subject-specific, multidimensional relationships between performance and confidence that serve as stable metacognitive signatures.In a third study, we apply this framework to an aging cohort, comparing each older adult’s BP to that of a young adult reference group using a cognitive/value-based task (“Hot or Not”). We show that individual differences in BP similarity to the young adult profile negatively correlate with gray matter volume in frontal, temporal, and sensorimotor regions, as revealed by voxel-based morphometry (VBM).Together, these findings signal a conceptual and methodological shift in the field of metacognition—toward standardized, individualized, and biologically grounded assessments of metacognitive stability—laying the groundwork for future investigations across domains, populations, and neurodiverse profiles.
Author: Ceja, Vanessa
Institution: University of California, Irvine
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funders: Strong, University of California, Irvine
OpenAlex ID: W7023531328
