Pathways towards organic aquaculture (shrimp) : challenges, potentials and risks under a livelihood perspective
Year: 2013
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Increased international demand for seafood and the involvement of multinational corporations in the commercialization of organic seafood have greatly enhanced organic shrimp aquaculture practices in Bangladesh.Based on the example of organic shrimp farming in Bangladesh, this research examines whether conversion to an organic aquaculture system can be a viable option for improving the livelihoods of farmers.The shrimp industry employs approximately 1.2 million people in Bangladesh and provides livelihood for an estimated 4.8 million household members.Development agencies and companies are increasingly trying to utilize this potential by organizing organic farmers' groups, and linking them to the growing market demand in industrialized countries.The study was carried out in view of a sustainable livelihood approach of the Department For International Development, sustainability science defined by the World Commission on Environment and Development, and the diffusion of innovation theory developed by the rural sociologist Everett M. Rogers.Focus group discussions, transect walks, and questionnaire surveys were employed in 2009 with 144 organic, 60 conventional, and 60 integrated (with fish and rice) shrimp farmers.Negative criticisms such as mangrove destruction, salt water intrusion, water pollution, disease outbreak, low yield, high input cost, low price, market fluctuation, livelihood displacement, and social unrest have challenged and jeopardized the future growth of sustainable shrimp aquaculture.However, the results show that by substituting synthetic fertilizers and pesticides with locally available resources and family labor, organic shrimp farming in Bangladesh not only has the potential to improve natural resource management, but also to increase yield (320 kg ha -1 yr -1 in organic production compared to 226 kg ha -1 yr -1 in conventional production), to reduce production costs, and to obtain a better price for the produce (annually 10-20% higher in organic compared to conventional farmers).Surprisingly, organic shrimp farming did not require significantly more labor than conventional and integrated systems.Due to lower production costs and a price premium for "organic" food, the average annual gross margins from organic shrimp were higher (10-20%) than those of conventional and integrated systems.The greatest effect of organic aquaculture on the farm household was observed in income and employment.Lower production costs and higher incomes help organic shrimp farmers to minimize their vulnerability to uncertain causes such as occurrence of natural disaster, shrimp disease, and market demand fluctuations.The adoption of organic shrimp farming requires the farmer to acquire new knowledge and skills, and a change of attitude.The economic constraints of the conversion period emerged as an important entrance barrier to the adoption of organic shrimp farming, especially for small and medium scale farmers.Government, research organizations, development agencies, and multinational companies should work together to formulate integrated policies that will help organic shrimp farmers to reduce vulnerability, obtain certification, and overcome market fluctuations.
Author: Paul, Brojo Gopal
Language: English
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funders: U.S. Department of Agriculture, United States Agency for International Development, World Wildlife Fund, Department for International Development, UK Government, European Commission, Österreichische Agentur für Internationale Mobilität und Kooperation in Bildung, Wissenschaft und Forschung, OeAD-GmbH, Danish International Development Agency
OpenAlex ID: W7023590398
