Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The present research proposes and tests a causal model of how people believe and share misinformative news, as opposed to informative news. In a within-subjects experiment, we presented ten news publications with political content, extracted from Facebook, to 259 Portuguese participants. We tested the impact of individuals' prior political beliefs in judging the veracity and probability of sharing informative and misinformative news publications, via perceived emotion (surprise and interest) and credibility (trustworthiness, rigorosity, impartiality). The results showed that participants' ability to distinguish truth from lies was quite limited. Misinformative and informative news were processed in a similar way. Emotional and credibility cues did not only depend on objective news content, but also on prior beliefs. Negative beliefs about the political system increased emotionality in the processing of true and false news. Moreover, greater emotionality increased perceptions of credibility, which in turn increased perceived veracity and probability of sharing news (true or false). The most distinct difference between the two types of news was that participants with more negative beliefs about the political system were more willing to share objectively misinformative news, and more surprised by news (informative or misinformative) they considered to be false, with surprise increasing the probability of sharing such news despite their perceived falsehood. We conclude that people seem to rely on emotional cues, appraised with regard to prior beliefs, and on emotionally biased credibility indicators to guess whether news are true or - independent on veracity - worth sharing.
Source: Repositório do ISCTE-IUL
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7025155128
