Work

Poverty of the Stimulus' Revisited: Recent Challenges Reconsidered

Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: A central goal of modern generative grammar has been to discover the invariant properties of language, presumably "part of the innate schematism of mind that is applied to the data of experience" and that "might reasonably be attributed to the organism itself as its contribution to the task of the acquisition of knowledge" (Chomsky, 1971).One such putative principle is the structure dependence of grammatical rules generally, including rules of question formation.One argument for this position, presented in Chomsky (1968), is sometimes called an 'argument from the poverty of the stimulus' (POS) since the sample data for selecting a correct target hypothesis does not seem rich enough without positing a priori the principle in question.Recently, several researchers have claimed that this POS argument can be deflected without resort to this 'innate schematism,' among these a string substitutability procedure (Clark & Eyraud, 2006), or a Bayesian model selection algorithm that adjudicates between regular and context-free grammars (Perfors, Tennenbaum & Regier, 2006).We demonstrate that all these recent arguments fail.We conclude that the POS argument and its support for a priori structure dependence holds, without qualification.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W70254687
FWCI: 27.31
Cites: 32
Cited by: 24
Related to: 10