Work

The Ethnic and Social Determinants of Dementia

Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: Background Currently, more than 25,000 people live with dementia from Black and Asian Minority Ethnic (BAME) groups in the United Kingdom (UK), with an expected increase to over 172,000 people by 2051, highlighting a sevenfold increase compared to the twofold increase predicted for the rest of the UK population. Dementia is the leading cause of death in the UK, and its prevalence continues to rise. Despite the elevated prevalence of dementia among ethnic minorities in the UK, the diagnosis rates are believed to be underestimated. It has been proposed that a third of dementia risk may be preventable or treated, thereby delaying the onset and requiring timely diagnosis. The modifiable risk factors include diabetes, midlife hypertension, midlife obesity, physical inactivity, depression, smoking, low educational attainment, excessive alcohol consumption, traumatic brain injury, hearing loss, social isolation, and air pollution. However, evidence of dementia risk and variation in risk attributed to known modifiable risk factors have primarily been explored in populations of European ancestry. It remains unclear whether the potential to prevent and reduce dementia cases by targeting modifiable risk factors is shared across ethnic groups and socioeconomic status. Methods This research is fundamentally anchored in two extensive and credible data collections: the East London General Practice (ELGP) study, extracted from the Discovery East London integrated dataset, and the UK Biobank (UKB) cohort study. The ELGP study had a cross-sectional design, and consists of primary care electronic health data from over 1.1 million adult patients registered at 167 general practices in four CCGs in East London, specifically, Hackney & City of London, Newham, Tower Hamlets, and Waltham Forest. The UKB is a cohort study with 502,656 participants who lived near one of 22 recruitment centres, aged 40-69 years at baseline, and who were recruited between 2006-2010. Medline and Embase databases were searched on the 17th of March 2020 using the terms “deprivation”, “socioeconomic status”, “nationality”, “race”, “ethnicity”, “ethnic group”, “Alzheimer's disease”, and “dementia”. Subsequently, both the ELGP and UKB share the endpoint of all-cause dementia diagnosis, although they diverge considerably in their methodological approaches. All-cause dementia was defined as a dated diagnosis of all-cause dementia (e.g. Alzheimer’s disease, vascular dementia, frontotemporal dementia, dementia in other classified diseases, unspecified dementia). Findings Within the ELGP, a total of 4,137 dementia cases and 15,754 matched controls were identified. The mean age for dementia cases was 80.7 years (SD,8.7), 81.3 years (SD,8.9) in matched controls, and 40.5 years (SD,15.4) for the entire population. The demographic distribution of the dementia cases was as follows: 60.3% were female, 47.5% were White, 22.7% were Black, and 16.6% were South Asians. On the other hand, the UKB had a median follow-up of 13.8 years, where 6,624 people developed dementia. The mean age at baseline for dementia cases was 64.2 years (SD,4.8), and 56.4 years (SD, 8.1) for the control population. Of the patients with dementia, 52.8% were male, 95.4% were White, 1.6% were Black, and 1.2% were South Asian. Furthermore, in my thesis, I show that, in a relatively deprived and ethnically diverse population in East London, those who identify as Black people are 43% more likely to develop dementia compared to those who identify as White, or South Asian people are 17% more likely. This disparity was not accounted for by area-level socioeconomic deprivation or by known modifiable risk factors. Black and South Asian ethnicities were both associated with a younger age at dementia diagnosis relative to their White counterparts: ORs [95% CI]: Black 0.70 [0.61-0.80] and South Asian 0.55 [0.47-0.65]. The combined weighted PAF in this East London population for all modifiable risk factors and sociodemographic risk factors (ethnicity and deprivation) was 21.0%. In addition, ethnicity and deprivation had higher population attributable fractions (PAF [95%CI]) than any of the more established modifiable clinical risk factors and health behaviours, suggesting that they are important independent associations of dementia risk: severe socioeconomic deprivation (4.7%), combined ethnic minorities (4.6%) [Black ethnicity = 3.3%, and South Asian ethnicity = 1.3%], compared to depression (4.0%), head injury (1.3%), underweight (0.7%), diabetes (3.6%), hearing loss (1.1%), and hypertension (1.2%). These results suggest that identifying and targeting modifiable factors underlying the increased risk attributable to ethnicity and deprivation could potentially prevent a greater proportion of dementia cases. Secondly, I examined a relatively affluent and healthy population in the UK, using the UK Biobank cohort study. Furthermore, results from the UK Biobank validated the increased dementia risk linked to 11 of the 12 modifiable risk factors outlined by the 2020 Lancet Commission, with the exception of excessive alcohol consumption. Black ethnicity was 28% more likely to develop dementia than their White counterparts, which was not observed for South Asian ethnicity. In addition, the most deprived participants were 56% more likely to develop dementia than the least deprived. However, after accounting for all major modifiable risk factors, the strength of the association was dismissed in Black ethnicity and significantly reduced in the most deprived group. There remained ethnic disparities in the PAF of potentially modifiable risk factors of dementia, as observed in East London, with BIPOC having a higher PAF attributed to known modifiable risk factors, compared to White participants (PAF [95%CI]): South Asian = 49.8% [48.7-50.9]; Black = 0.2% [39.2-41.3]; and White = 38.4% [38.2-38.5]. Interventions for depression and hypertension were found to be a priority in South Asian and Black participants, respectively. Finally, the most socioeconomically deprived group in this population had significantly higher PAFs than the wealthiest group (PAF [95%CI]): Most deprived participants = 40.3% [40.0-40.6]; versus less deprived participants = 27.2% [27.0-27.5]. Thus, showing that a small proportion of potentially preventable dementia cases in this group will benefit from reducing or preventing these risk factors. Public health interventions to support those with a deprived background are a priority and potentially an effective dementia prevention strategy. Interpretation In this thesis, I have taken an intersectional approach to evaluate ethnic and socioeconomic (measured as area-level deprivation and individual material deprivation) differences in their effect on modifiable risk factors for dementia, using electronic health records of over a million people in East London, alongside a nationally representative cohort population with up to 17 years of follow-up. This thesis highlights the complex interactions between area-level socioeconomic deprivation, ethnicity, and health conditions that may negatively affect brain health, with potential socioeconomic factors dampening the impact of ethnicity. The variations observed in the proportion of potentially preventable dementia cases among different ethnic and socioeconomic groups, necessitate a nuanced approach to future enquiries. There is a pressing need to delve deeper into the complexities that contribute to potentially preventable dementia cases across diverse demographic settings and to specify racial groups within major ethnic groups. The data strongly advocate the development of targeted culturally sensitive interventions. This should be based on an intricate understanding of the factors contributing to potentially preventable dementia cases across different demographic groups. Overall, policies aimed at reducing the population burden of dementia will need to address any structural factors underlying this variation in dementia risk to minimise brain health inequalities.
Author: Bothongo, P
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7028361635
FWCI:
Cites: 258
Cited by:
Related to: 9