Promoting positive mental health in the postpartum period: Randomized controlled trial of a web-based CBT intervention for low-risk postpartum women
Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Background Mental illness during the postpartum period has been associated with several long-term negative consequences for the mother’s health and the child’s development and has also been linked to a significant economic burden on society. Psychological interventions could play a central role in reducing the human and economic costs associated with mental illness in this period. However, research suggests that focusing solely on treatment and prevention of mental illness may not be enough. A strategy that goes beyond targeting at-risk groups for prevention and treatment could lead to significant mental health benefits in population terms. Research findings suggest that while treatment and prevention have a crucial role to play in the short term, the way to reduce the prevalence of mental disorders in the long term is to intervene seeking to elevate positive mental health levels at the general population level. During the postpartum period, women face several practical and attitudinal barriers that keep them from seeking traditional face-to-face professional help. e-Mental health tools for mental health promotion can be particularly helpful, given their accessibility and flexibility. These interventions can serve as helpful mental health promotion tools that can be delivered to a broad population. In this context, Be a Mom was developed to be a web-based intervention based in cognitive behavioral therapy principles, aiming to promote maternal mental health among postpartum women. The general aims of our study were: 1) to understand the relevance of measuring and addressing positive mental health in the postpartum period; and 2) to test the overall efficacy, acceptability, feasibility and cost-effectiveness of Be a Mom among postpartum women presenting low risk for postpartum depression. Methods This research project comprised two phases. Phase I consisted of a cross-sectional study which focused on: 1) the psychometric studies of the Mental Health Continuum-Short Form [MHC-SF]; and, 2) the examination of the factors (sociodemographic, health‐related, infant‐related, and psychological factors) associated with flourishing and postpartum depressive symptoms among postpartum women. Phase II consisted of a randomized controlled trial evaluating the efficacy of Be a Mom vs. a waiting-list control group among postpartum women presenting low risk for PPD. A total of 367 participants were randomly assigned to the Be a Mom group (n = 191) or to the waiting-list control group (n = 176) and completed baseline (T1), postintervention (T2), four and 12 months after postintervention assessments (T3 and T4, respectively). Participants completed self-report questionnaires assessing individual outcomes (e.g., positive mental health, depressive symptoms), maternal outcomes (e.g., maternal self-efficacy), relationship outcomes (e.g., relationship satisfaction), psychological processes (e.g., self-compassion, emotion regulation), QALYs and data related to healthcare and productivity costs. Results In phase I, results showed that the MHC-SF is a valid measure for use in the postpartum context. Confirmatory factor analysis showed that the bifactor model yielded a significantly better fit to the data than the original correlated three-factor model. The results also suggested a strong general factor of positive mental health and did not support the use of the subscale scores. Additionally, our results showed that the factors that contribute to flourishing in the postpartum period differed from those associated with not presenting depressive symptoms. In particular, younger infant age, higher levels of maternal confidence, and resilience increased the likelihood of flourishing. In turn, higher income, fewer problems with an infant's sleep, perceiving an infant's temperament as easy, and higher psychological flexibility increased the likelihood of not having depressive symptoms. Appraising the support received by others as good and having higher self-compassion increased the likelihood of both outcomes. In phase II, our findings showed that, compared to the control group, the intervention group reported significant increases in positive mental health and self-compassion between T1 and T2. Group effects were found for depressive and anxiety symptoms and emotion regulation. Additionally, we found that increases in self-compassion from T1 to T2 significantly contributed to the improvement in positive mental health. Moreover, results indicated that Be a Mom is a cost-effective intervention. At a €0 willingness to pay threshold, there is a 96% probability that the intervention is cost-effective when compared with the control group. Different sensitivity analysis generally supported the acceptable likelihood of the intervention being more cost-effective than the control group. Conclusions The findings of this research project highlight the need of a paradigm shift in current perinatal clinical and research contexts, from a sole focus on mental illness to a more comprehensive approach that includes the assessment and promotion of positive mental health. It also emphasizes the potential of web-based interventions in delivering (cost-)effective mental health interventions. A pathway which uses eHealth interventions aimed at promoting positive mental health among low-risk postpartum women seems to play a significant role in managing the current high burden of postpartum mental illness.
Author: Monteiro, Fabiana Garcia
Institution: University of Coimbra
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: positive mental health, postpartum depression, postpartum women, internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy, eudaimonia, Mental Health Continuum-Short Form, e-mental health, maternal mental health, treatment acceptability, cost-effectiveness, postpartum depressive symptoms, psychometric validation, waiting list control group, long-term intervention
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7033584405
