Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: What explains why pogroms target communities in some locations, but not in others?In this dissertation, I introduce a theory of pogroms that explains how the spatial pattern of pogrom violence varies systematically across four different types of political order: (1) consolidated, in which state actors provide explicit support to organizers with a broad base of social support; (2) state-building, in which organizers draw on explicit state support and a thin base of social sup-port; (3) contested, which involve implicit state support and broad-networked organizers; and (4) anarchic, in which state actors provide implicit support to thin-networked organizers.I hypothesize that pogrom participants will target highly visible groups in consolidated and anarchic orders, whereas state-building and contested orders will follow from underlying patterns of political threat and economic competition, respectively.I test these hypotheses in four archetypal pogrom cases: Kristallnacht, in Nazi Germany in November 1938, is the consolidated case; La Matanza, against the Mexican population of the Lower Rio Grande Valley, in 1915, is the state-building case; the pogrom against the Black population of East St. Louis, IL, in 1917, is the contested case; and the anti-Caribbean violence in the London neighborhood of Notting Hill, in 1958, is the anarchic case.I use spatial regression analysis to test plausible explanations for pogrom attacks, using novel quantitative data that I collected and compiled from diverse historical sources.I find modest, but inconsistent, evidence in favor of the symbolic theory.In the Kristallnacht case, synagogue attacks were more likely where the Jewish population share was large.In the Lower Rio Grande Valley case, participants were more likely to organize anti-Mexican violence where previous attacks by so-called "bandits" were thought to pose a threat to the Anglo-dominated iii I have benefited from extraordinary professional, intellectual, and personal assistance in the six years since I began work on this project.I defended my dissertation proposal in November 2020, nearly one year into the COVID-19 pandemic.A large community of fellow scholars, colleagues, and family helped me start, work on, and complete my dissertation despite that sprawling crisis of health and collective well-being.Although I take personal responsibility for whatever errors appear in these pages, I extend these acknowledgments as a small token of appreciation for the collective accomplishment that this dissertation represents.By design, this dissertation abstracts away much of the experience of horrific violence.The "spatial pattern of violence" that I seek to explain in the following chapters is an aggregate summary of millions of individual encounters with mass atrocities, in which agents of violence kill, maim, and humiliate people whom they do not recognize as fully human.Whatever analytic value I take away from the quantitative analyses that make up my research, I do so recalling the profound burden of harm that victims and survivors of pogroms experience.I hope that this dissertation draws attention, however scant, to the importance of taking that experience of victimization and its political implications seriously.The community of scholars studying political violence, both in political science and in other disciplines, has been a generous source of intellectual engagement and advice throughout my PhD research.Thank you to my dissertation committee: my chair, Laia
Author: Solomon, Daniel Ethan
Institution: State Historical Society of Missouri
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7034127214
