Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: ABSTRACT \n \nSuicide remains an important issue for mental health professionals, with 44,193 deaths by suicide in 2015. The current response to a client experiencing a suicidal crisis is to collaboratively construct a crisis response plan. A crisis response plan is a document that outlines coping strategies intended to help a client resolve a suicidal crisis. Crisis response plans are made up of several content areas all designed to assist a client with effectively managing urges and thoughts related to suicide. With the increased prevalence of smartphones in the United States, researchers have begun to explore the potential for smartphones to augment and improve psychological treatment. Currently, the existing literature contains no examples of a digital application replacing a traditional treatment instrument, only in augmenting traditional treatments. However, the technology of smartphones presents an opportunity to improve access to therapeutic tools in an unprecedented way. \n \nParticipants in this study were 14 clients undergoing treatment at the Texas Tech University Psychology Clinic or Texas Tech Student Counseling Center who used either a pencil-and-paper crisis response plan or the My3 application, a digital recreation of a crisis response plan, for three weeks before switching to the alternate crisis response plan format for three additional weeks of data collection. Client self-report data was collected during each participant’s weekly therapy session for six consecutive weeks. It was hypothesized (1) that the My3 application will be more effective at reducing suicide ideation than the pencil-and-paper crisis response plan, (2) that participants using the My3 application will report a greater degree of satisfaction with their crisis response plan than participants using the pencil-and-paper crisis response plan, and (3) that the ease of use afforded by the My3 application will explain the greater effectiveness of the smartphone application crisis response plan. A small-n repeated measures design was used to test these hypotheses. \n \nData analyses using the reliable change index (RCI) were conducted for each of the hypotheses. Overall, there was mixed support for the hypotheses. Data for five participants supported hypothesis 1. Hypothesis 2 was not supported for any of participants. Hypothesis 3 was similarly not supported using the current sample. Ultimately, the current study provided preliminary data for future research into the effectiveness of smartphone applications as tools to augment clinical practice. The current study does not indicate superiority of the My3 application over the pencil-and-paper measures commonly used. However, it also does not suggest that there is any harm in using the two formats of crisis response plan in concert. Future investigations into the effectiveness of smartphone applications such as the My3 should attempt a randomized clinical trial design that would provide more definitive support for the use of a smartphone application alongside or in place of a pencil-and-paper crisis response plan. There is also some indication that suicide ideation alone may not be the optimal metric for effectiveness in such a study. With that in mind, future research may consider an alternate outcome variable.
Author: Guidry, Evan T.
Institution: Texas Tech University
Language: English
Subfield: Applied Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7034450798
