Work

The Views of Educational Psychologists about Neuroscience: \nA Discourse Analysis

Year: 2012
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The field of neuroscience has received more and more publicity over recent \nyears, specifically by its claims to contribute to the understanding of childrens' \nlearning, education and development. However, progress in neuroscience \nfindings and its links with education have also been subject to controversy, \nparticularly with regard to how far the brain can inform understanding of social \nprocesses. While educational psychologists have been identified as a discipline \npotentially central to the debates about neuroscience (Hall, 2004), little research \nhas yet investigated the views of educational psychologists about the value or \nrelevance of this field in their discipline. \nThis research presents an analysis of views of ten educational psychologists \nfrom two Local Authority services. The researcher carried out semi-structured \ninterviews and analysed the data using two approaches from the Discourse \nAnalytic tradition. Methods from Discursive Psychology and Foucauldian \nDiscourse Analysis were used to investigate how educational psychologists \ndiscursively constructed the role of neuroscience in their discipline. \nThe combination of research tools yielded rich interview data. Ten discursive \nsites were identified. Neuroscience was simultaneously viewed and identified \ndiscursively as the Identification of Pathology or Deficit, an Additional \nExplanatory Model, A Challenge to the Social Constructionist Worldview, and \nKnowledge for Responsibility and Duty. Implications of these findings for \nEducational Psychology practice are discussed. The prevalence of professional \neclecticism in the discipline was evident. Reference to educational \npsychologists’ frameworks and models for practice were notable and was \nconsidered as points for discussion. Educational psychologists’ constructions \ngave rise to a variety of different subject positions, and therefore the actions \nthat are made possible by these positions. Methodological issues are also \nconsidered, together with suggestions for future research.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7034725241
Cites: 69
Cited by:
Related to: 10