Accountability practices from a micro-institutional and relational perspective. A cross-national qualitative case study
Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Based on a review of the social work literature, we identified three gaps in research on accountability: 1. The conceptualisation of accountability is one-sidedly framed in new public management theory. This is problematic in two ways. Firstly, new public management does not provide a solution for accountability of social work practice. It undermines the professionalism of social workers and is a bad fit with the relational and complex nature of practice. Secondly, this biased conceptualisation disregards the fact that accountability is more than an element of new public management. 2. Current studies mainly explore accountability practices at the organisational level. Because of this organisational focus, social workers' agency in the accountability process is not taken into account. How social workers give meaning to the different accountability relations in their daily work and how they deal with the dilemmas and tensions that arise from multiple and conflicting perspectives are questions that remain unanswered. 3. Current research is mainly conducted in Anglo-Saxon contexts. Because of the lack of comparative research, little is known about how divergent institutional configurations interact with accountability practices of social workers (M ller, 2019; Pollit & Bouckaert, 2011). In other words, the complex interplay between the street and institutional levels remains a black box. We address these gaps by broadening the conceptualisation of accountability, exploring how social workers give meaning to the three types of accountabilities and moral dilemmas in practice, and by applying a comparative, micro-institutional research approach. We broadened the conceptualisation by defining accountability as a central feature of professionalism and an important precondition for institutional democracy, and developing a relational conceptualisation that reflects the multiple accountability relations in social work. By exploring the accountability actions and beliefs of social workers in a public organisation and social workers in a private organisation across three cases, we provide insight into how social workers give meaning to the three types of accountability relations, as well as into their moral agency in relation to the moral dilemmas they are confronted with as a result of conflicting expectations. We deployed a comparative, micro-institutional research design to systematically capture macro level institutions, such as social workers' professional identity and organisational characteristics, that frame and/or restrict social workers' actions and beliefs and are shaped by social workers' agency. This helped us open the black box of the interplay between streetlevel agency and institutions. By comparing three cross-national cases, we included a variety of social-political contexts in our analysis, and by using Rice's micro-institutional model we were able to build a conceptual bridge between the accountability practices of social workers (micro-level) and institutions at meso (organisational policy and culture) and macro levels (social policy). 6.2 Research aim and questions The central aim of the study is to open up the debate about accountability in social work and contribute to the theory development on accountability practices in social work. In pursuing this aim, the study has two research objectives. The first objective is to explore how social workers give meaning to the three types of accountabilities across practical contexts. By 'meaning', we mean social workers' actions and beliefs (Fairclouth, 2003), and how social workers manage the different perspectives of these accountability relations and the tensions that arise from them. The second objective is to explore how these actions and beliefs interact with the institutional context in which social workers are embedded, which we referred to earlier as the micro-macro relationship. To realise this aim, we formulated the following three research questions. Research question 1: Which accountability relations are studied between 2007-2017, and what do these studies conclude about the way social workers account for their work in these relations? Research question 2: How do social workers across different practical contexts account for their work on the three types of accountability relations? Research question 3: Which micro-institutional attributes can be identified that interact with the accountability practices of social workers? To address the research questions formulated above, we conducted four research projects. Table 2 at the next page summarizes the main characteristics of these four projects. Each project was designed around one of the three types of accountability relations and around distinct features of the institutional context, which enabled us to empirically examine the micro-macro relationship. The first project addresses the first and the second research questions. In this project, we conducted a scoping review of empirical studies in nine social work journals, published between 2007 and 2017. The aim was to scope research findings on the three types of accountabilities. We reviewed which types of mechanisms were studied and how they are used by social workers in practice. We also included descriptive information on the types of methodology used in the studies and the country in which the studies were conducted. The second, third and fourth research projects addressed the second and third research questions with through a cross-national case studies in which we zoomed in on the three types of accountability relations and specific mechanisms in institutional contexts. In the second research project, we explored the accountability relation between the government-funded shelter facility, as an example of political-administrative accountability. By building on resource dependence theory, we explored how social workers accounted for their work to the government, and how this was affected by social policy institutions. In the third research project, we explored social workers' accountability relationship with professional peers and professional standards, as an example of professional accountability. We used Maynard-Moody & Musheno's (2013) theory of 'citizen and state narratives' to examine how the social workers of a local welfare organisation navigated between both narratives, and how this was affected by organisational institutions. In the fourth research project, we explored social workers' accountability relationship with citizens and service users, as an example of participative-democratic accountability. We used Dzur's (2019) theory of democratic professionalism to explore the theoretical validity and practical usefulness of democratic professionalism for social work. We searched for empirical examples of democratic professionalism in our cross-national case study data. More specifically, we searched for examples that show how democratic professionals can bridge the gap between citizens and social institutions. We also explored how these democratic practices are affected by distinct features of the policy environment (macro-level).
Source: Lirias
Author: van der Tier, Michelle
Language: English
Subfield: Public Administration
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: accountability, social work practice, New Public Management, moral agency, ethical dilemmas, relational accountability, institutional democracy, street-level bureaucracy, professional identity, organizational culture, cross-national comparison, institutional configuration, social work ethics, social work knowledge, social work skills
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7035930913
