Work

Besluitvorming door executive teams onder druk. A multiple-case studie in de Nederlandse financiële sector.

Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Executive team decision making under stress: A multiple-case study in the Dutch financial industry Every day, executives around the globe take important strategic decisions that can cause great harm. The Global Financial Crisis, BP's oil spill in the Mexican Gulf and the two consecutive air crashes with the Boeing 737 Max vividly demonstrate how severe the effects of ill-taken decisions can be. Beneath these disasters there seems to lie a pattern. Driven by competitive pressures or the shortsighted pursuit of profit and growth, executives take excessive risks, while disregarding the harm it can cause to others. Despite its importance, to date not a lot is known about what executive teams actually do when they take complex strategic decisions. Empirical academic studies are scarce, and theories on executive decision making aiming to establish relations between certain team features and firm performance are (often) inconclusive. Moreover, the literature is scattered. This study aims to fill these gaps. First, by exploring and describing what executives actually do when they take decisions. Second, by exploring which capabilities executive teams must possess to take effective decisions, i.e. decisions that are characterized by balanced tradeoffs between diverging and often competing interests. For the aforementioned exploratory purposes a qualitative multiple-case study was conducted. This study was based on a unique sample of 49 anonymized case studies into top executive teams operating in the Dutch financial industry. These real life case studies were conducted between 2011 and 2018 by teams of senior supervisors, including experienced (social and organizational) psychologists, under the responsibility of the Dutch Central Bank ("DNB"), as part of its supervision of financial firms. To guide the study, a heuristic model was designed, which integrated five different fields related to executive decision making and which included the cognitive taskwork and teamwork variables (and their antecedents) that determine decision effectiveness. In terms of outcomes, the study includes a wealth of detailed descriptions of decision making practices. It further makes clear that balanced tradeoffs require the identification, consideration and integration of diverse and diverging perspectives into a single coherent decision. Finally, the study demonstrates that this perspective integration strongly depends on the interactional and relational processes between executive team members. Implications for theory, research and practices are discussed.
Author: Nuijts, Wijnandus Hermanus Johannes Maria
Institution: KU Leuven
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7036225571
Cites: 206
Cited by:
Related to: 10