Climate Change in UNCLOS – A study of State obligations and responsibility in light of the 2024 ITLOS Advisory Opinion
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The urgency of the climate change crisis calls for global efforts. Mitigation of GHG-pollution within international law consists of the interaction of multiple legal areas. Given the importance of the oceans in climate regulation, the international law of the sea and UNCLOS are important in protecting the marine environment. By the use of the legal dogmatic method, the essay seeks to examine the obligations and responsibilities of States under UNCLOS regarding climate change, specifically in light of the 2024 ITLOS advisory opinion. The issue of climate change in international law is mitigated both through climate change treaties, general principles of law and the international law of the sea. The marine environmental protection framework in Part XII UNCLOS is in many ways well-adjusted in terms of combating these global issues. The two main obligations identified in this essay is article 192, on the protection and preservation of the marine environment, and article 194, which call for necessary measures in terms of marine pollution, the contents of which were further specified in the 2024 ITLOS advisory opinion. Eventual breaches of these obligations can be addressed either through UNCLOS or the international regime regarding State responsibility. The ITLOS opinion did not consider questions of liability and responsibility, but multiple scholars have commented the legal situation and highlight certain existing legal gaps making it hard to pursue interstate claims of these breaches. The results of the investigation show that the legal obligations of States in Part XII UNCLOS, mainly as a result of the important findings in the ITLOS opinion, are far-reaching and maintains a high standard of due diligence. Fur-thermore, the essay concludes that there are various mechanisms for establish-ing responsibility for breaches of climate change obligations in UNCLOS. Making out a claim meets certain challenges, mainly the issues regarding scientific attribution of GHG-emissions, the fragmentation of relevant legal regimes and the unspecified character of the primary rules, specifically article 192 and 194 of UNCLOS. The extent to which responsibility can be attributed States for breaches of climate change obligations is particularly affected by these legal uncertainties.
Author: Karlsson, Melissa
Institution: Lund University
Language: English
Subfield: Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7036698547
