Engage for What? How Normative, Political, and Affective Forces Enable and Constrain Participation in Equitable Education Reform
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: As racial inequities are increasingly coming into focus and we are living through both a crisis of legitimacy in democratic processes and a crisis of care in which the social reproductive work of caring for children and others becomes increasingly difficult, school districts must grapple with ways of engaging and supporting youth, teachers, and communities in shaping equity-oriented reforms. The traditional mechanisms that school districts have used for engaging and collaborating in educational reform have failed to sufficiently address racialized opportunity gaps in education. This dissertation examines some of the ways that marginalized people participate in and lead attempts to change policies and practices in schools and build collective power to address racial inequities. Specifically, it seeks to answer the research question: How do habits, normative ideas, political forces, and social relations based on multiple and shifting identities enable and constrain who collaborates, engages, and participates in shaping equity-oriented reforms, as well as how they do so, and how such participation, collaboration, engagement, in turn, can shift those forces? I conducted three case studies—in New York City, New England, and Miami — sites with some political similarities and many differences, in which people who participated in educational reform efforts negotiated both sanctioned and unsanctioned spaces for participation. I examined how the process of participation shaped the reform itself and challenged or reinforced existing power dynamics. Using a mix of critical ethnographic methods within each case study, I explored the ways in which these stakeholders engaged with political and normative forces at the local level. Using comparative case study methodology to understand the similarities and differences between districts, I found that a district’s inclusive orientation towards education reform can improve implementation. Additionally, the ways that participants used counterpublic spaces to build affective ties, develop political consciousness, and practice governing power to then be able to shift the way others in the district understood and felt about the reforms reflected the Black radical tradition (Morgan, 2021; Robinson, 2020). These approaches allowed them to develop strategies to shift the zone of mediation, by creating opportunities for affective, political, and normative shifts that then made them able to create deeper change. This research demonstrates the ways that exclusion from democratic processes and exploitation of reproductive labor can both enable and constrain how marginalized people participate in education reform efforts and the ways that people continue to resist in the face of challenges. In all three cases, the types of participation, who participated in the reform efforts, and what was considered acceptable by the districts were shaped by normative, political, and affective forces, while participants found multiple ways to resist and in turn shifted those forces to build more collective power, political analysis, and affective ties that strengthened their organizing for equitable reforms.
Author: Daniel, Julia Armsden
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: educational equity, school district reform, participatory democracy, counterpublics, Black radical tradition, affective bonds, political consciousness, collective power, power relations, marginalized stakeholders, New York City, New England, Miami, community involvement in education, student and teacher participation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7037737342
