Work

Neural plasticity and the limits of scientific knowledge

Year: 2015
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Western science claims to provide unique, objective information about the world. This \nis supported by the observation that peoples across cultures will agree upon a common \ndescription of the physical world. Further, the use of scientific instruments and \nmathematics is claimed to enable the objectification of science. \n \nIn this work, carried out by reviewing the scientific literature, the above claims are \ndisputed systematically by evaluating the definition of physical reality and the scientific \nmethod, showing that empiricism relies ultimately upon the human senses for the \nevaluation of scientific theories and that measuring instruments cannot replace the \nhuman sensory system. \n \nNativist and constructivist theories of human sensory development are reviewed, and it \nis shown that nativist claims of core conceptual knowledge cannot be supported by the \nfindings in the literature, which shows that perception does not simply arise from a \nprocess of maturation. Instead, sensory function requires a long process of learning \nthrough interactions with the environment. \n \nTo more rigorously define physical reality and systematically evaluate the stability of \nperception, and thus the basis of empiricism, the development of the method of \ndimension analysis is reviewed. It is shown that this methodology, relied upon for the \nmathematical analysis of physical quantities, is itself based upon empiricism, and that \nall of physical reality can be described in terms of the three fundamental dimensions of \nmass, length and time. \n \nHereafter the sensory modalities that inform us about these three dimensions are \nsystematically evaluated. The following careful analysis of neuronal plasticity in these \nmodalities shows that all the relevant senses acquire from the environment the capacity \nto apprehend physical reality. It is concluded that physical reality is acquired rather than \ngiven innately, and leads to the position that science cannot provide unique results. \nRather, those it can provide are sufficient for a particular environmental setting.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7039883748
Cites: 491
Cited by:
Related to: 10