Year: 2008
Type: article
Abstract: Is innocence still irrelevant?In his influential 1970 article, Judge Henry Friendly provocatively asked why innocence is irrelevant to federal habeas corpus review. 1 Judge Friendly proposed that innocence should provide a ground for relief from a criminal conviction, but his call went unheeded, perhaps because at that time innocence could rarely be proven with any certainty.For reasons of reliability, courts distrusted exculpatory witnesses who came forward years after a trial, when their memories had faded and their motives were suspect.In addition, forensic evidence was usually not very probative.Claims asserting the existence of new evidence of innocence were considered fundamentally equivocal, and, as a result, states imposed strict rules of finality, barring claims brought after limitation periods expired.Thus, in the decades since Judge Friendly first asked whether innocence should be relevant to criminal appeals, the Supreme Court has repeatedly declined to 1. See
Source: Minnesota law review
DOI: 10.24926/265535.1508
Author: Brandon L. Garrett
Language: English
Topic: Criminal Law and Evidence
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7139080875
