Work

Proposições Certas - Pressuposições do Inquérito Epistémico

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In this dissertation, ideas concerning propositions with certainty, proposed by two authors, Crispin Wright and Roderick Chisholm, are analysed.Wright's project (2004a; 2004b;2014) sparks from his interpretation of Wittgenstein's hinge epistemology (1969), by advancing the thesis that some hinges are cornerstone propositions, a new category Wright has introduced.Therefore, hinges are propositions and Wright suggests that cornerstone propositions, which are out of the scope of evidence, and therefore can't be empirically justified, have epistemic warrant of a specific kind -an entitlement, that is distinguishable from justification because it's independent from propositional reasons.Epistemic inquiry is a result of cornerstone propositions.Chisholm (1966;1977;1989) also developed an epistemic theory that includes propositions that give rise to epistemic inquiry, even though he doesn't use this expression.He proposes that two groups of certain propositions, encompassing the axiomatic and the self-evident, provide the foundations for a priori and a posteriori knowledge.Both authors feature some similar points.In this dissertation, I suggest a definition of certain propositions that preserves their original motivations: certainty is the basis of epistemic inquiry.It's possible to develop this view by working only with propositions (such as Chisholm suggests) and their new ways of characterizing epistemic warrant (such as the types of entitlement proposed by Wright).This way, one can reach a proper study of certain propositions, interpreted as presuppositions to epistemic warrant, like both main authors seem to see it (even if in different ways).
Author: Tiago Emanuel Álvares Veloso
Language: Portuguese
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7042759139
Cites: 16
Cited by:
Related to: 10