The Role of Disparity in Travel Behavior in the Disproportionate Impact of Covid-19 on Ethnic Minorities in the Netherlands
Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Covid-19 has disrupted social norms and economic stability across the world. As the virus disseminated across nations, researchers rushed to delineate the causes and the consequences of the spread of the virus. Early findings highlighted a concerning disproportionate impact of Covid-19 among ethnic minorities, which have been disproportionally victimized by the novel respiratory virus, with studies reporting up to 3.6 times the likelihood of infection for ethnic minorities compared to their white counterpart (APM Research Lab, 2021; USA Facts, 2020; Gross et al., 2020). Early studies indicated healthcare and socio-economic inequities as fosters of the pandemic and its discriminatory behavior. However, weeks into the pandemic, researchers also identified transportation as another significant contributor to outbreaks and as a contributor to the disproportionate impact of Covid-19 among ethnic minorities (McLaren, 2020). Although much research has been conducted in assessing the effect of Covid-19 and imposed social distancing on people’s travel behavior and vice versa (with contrasting findings), considerably less attempted to discover the role that different travel behavior - with a special focus on public transport - played in the disproportionate impact of Covid-19 among ethnic minorities (McLaren, 2020). The absence of studies, even more Netherlands-based that investigate the role of disparity in travel behavior in the disproportionate impact of Covid-19 suffered by ethnic minorities, and the moral obligation at contributing to the scientific community at unveiling the fundamental sources of ethnic disparity to attempt to outline a remedy to it, have encouraged the development of this study. In order to fill the research gap, this study seeks to provide an answer to the following main research question: "To what extend disparity in travel behavior is influencing the disproportionate incidence of Covid-19 infections and deaths among ethnic minorities? And how can policy-makers and public transport providers best adapt public transport to future discriminatory health crises?". The answer to the main research questions and the related sub-questions (Chapter 1.5), will be formulated through the combination of a comprehensive literature review, a statistical analysis through the Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) technique, and with the execution of a policy analysis study. Firstly, the literature review will be used to develop an in-depth understanding of the Covid-19 implications on the multidimensional ethnic disparity experienced by minorities in the Netherlands and on the actual nature of this disparity in the Netherlands. Results from the literature review will be used as inputs for the conceptual model that will later function as the theoretical guideline for the rest of the study. The conceptual model will represent the theory and the logic backbone of the SEM analysis. Structural Equation Modeling is a statistical tool used in a wide range of fields, with a concentrated number of applications in the travel behavior field. It allows to analyze a researcher’s theoretical model and capture the causal influences of the indicated exogenous variables on the endogenous ones and the casual influences among exogenous variables (Golob, 2011). Results from both models confirmed the notion that, in the Netherlands, ethnic minorities are more likely to suffer from Covid-19 infections and related hospital admissions but are not more at risk of death compared to their Dutch counterparts. At the same time, unlike the initial hypothesis, both models showed that public transport does not represent a key driver behind the development of Covid-19 infections, death, and hospital admissions; instead, other socio-economic variables and, most notably, spatial variables could be considered significant drivers of the Covid-19 pandemic. Moreover, both models diminished the intermediating role of public transport in the relationship between ethnic background and Covid-19 records by demonstrating that the registered positive relationship between ethnic minority groups and Covid-19 variables can be sourced to their direct relationships and thus to something that might not have been included in the study. Therefore, travel behavior and the other intermediating variables such as socio-economic variables do not appear to contribute to the disproportionate number of Covid-19 implications among ethnic minorities. What the second model offers that the first does not is a deeper insight into how Covid-19 disproportionally impacts ethnic minorities. This model demonstrates that the registered disparity in healthcare outcomes varies between ethnic minority groups, showing the presence of disparity even within the ethnic minority segment of the population.
Author: Giancaspro, Vincenzo (author)
Institution: Delft University of Technology
Language: English
Subfield: Modeling and Simulation
Field: Mathematics
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7043209176
