Academic and Motivational Outcomes of Reading Ability Grouping in the Early Grades
Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: Ability grouping is a common instructional practice in the early grades, but little is known about its effects over time.This study examined long-term academic and motivational outcomes of reading ability grouping.Using data from the U.S. Department of Education's Early Childhood Longitudinal Study, Kindergarten Class of 2010-11, children's reading ability group placements in kindergarten were used to predict their reading achievement and aspects of their motivation for reading in third grade.Patterns of ability group placement from kindergarten through second grade were then identified and used to predict third-grade academic and motivational outcomes as well.Results show that both kindergarten ability group placement and placement patterns from grades K-2 predicted third-grade reading achievement.Kindergarten grouping also predicted students' perceived competence in reading, and K-2 placement patterns predicted both perceived competence and intrinsic motivation for reading in third grade.This research has implications for reading instruction in primary grades and underscores the importance of examining children's academic and motivational outcomes concurrently.2006;Pallas et al., 1994), but very few have also focused on students' motivation for learning.One exception is a study by Pallas et al. (1994), in which ability grouping was used to predict students' expectations for their academic success-a core construct in the motivation literature.Pallas and colleagues label aspects of their study as "crude," however, and note that additional research is needed to understand outcomes of ability grouping.The present study is designed to help address this need. SummaryEarly childhood education holds great promise as a catalyst for students' success in school and in life.Research exploring the outcomes of instructional practices used in the early grades is therefore critical for ensuring effective policy and pedagogy.This is especially true for practices like ability grouping that are both widely used and understudied.The present study addresses gaps in the literature on ability grouping and young children's motivation.In doing so, it offers a necessary critical lens through which to understand the benefits and risks of a popular early childhood classroom practice.
Author: Khandaker, Naima
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7045092419
