Work

Efectos de un entrenamiento de fuerza con material elástico versus medio acuático sobre la composición corporal, el hueso, el rendimiento motor y el bienestar en mujeres mayores

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Physical exercise in general and, especially, strength training represent an effective strategy to prevent and/or reverse certain physiological, cognitive, emotional and motor performance alterations in old people. In order to train strength, beside the body weight, there are various traditional materials such as free weights or machines. Although these means are effective, however are often expensive, difficult to access, or uncomfortable for old people. For this reason, it is important to seek for alternatives to these materials using others, innovative, inexpensive and accessible, such as variable resistance materials in their elastic form or in the aquatic environment. Even though studies have already been carried out demonstrating that strength training with elastic materials or in the aquatic environment are as effective as other more traditional devices, there are not enough scientific research focused on the possible differences between them, in terms of the effects that can be achieved with their use, applied to a population of older adults. In this way, the present study tries to compare the effectiveness of strength training using elastic materials versus the aquatic environment on body composition, bone, motor performance and physical, psychological and social well-being, in a population of sedentary older women. To this aim, a 32 weeks randomized clinical assay based on a sample composed of 84 sedentary elderly women and divided into three groups was carried out. The first group trained with elastic tubes (GT) (n = 27); the second group carried out equivalent training in the aquatic environment (GA) (n = 26); the third group (CG) was the reference (or control) group that did not perform any type of habitual physical activity in their sedentary lifestyle (n = 31). The two experimental groups performed strength training, with a frequency of 2 sessions per week, in which they performed 6 exercises focused on the development of strength in the extremities and trunk at a moderate-high intensity. The variables studied in this research were body composition (percentage of total fat), bone (CMO, BMD, and T-Score of the hip and spine), motor performance (muscular endurance, isometric strength, isokinetic strength, agility, dynamic and static balance, and aerobic endurance), and physical, psychological and social well-being (physical function, physical role, bodily pain, general health, vitality, social function, emotional role, and mental health). In order to perform the statistical analysis, the SPSS 22 program was used. First, the assumption of normality and homogeneity of the dependent variables was verified with the Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Levene tests, respectively. After that, an unidirectional analysis of variance (ANOVA) of repeated measures was considered to determine the effects of the training protocol in time (baseline and 32 weeks) and by group (control; elastic; aquatic environment) on the dependent variables analysed for composition. body, bone, and motor performance. Once significant differences were detected, a Bonferroni post-hoc test was applied to determine between which groups such differences occurred. Furthermore, a T-test was performed for related samples in order to detect a possible difference over time for each group. With the purpose of determining the effects of the training protocol on the non-parametric dependent variables of physical, psychological and social well-being, the Mann-Whitney U-test was performed to check the possible differences between groups and the Wilcoxon test to analyse the possible differences in the weather. To quantify the magnitude of the difference over time for each group and also between groups, the effect size was calculated. Furthermore, to highlight the existence of possible clinical relevance of the results, the minimum clinical relevance (MRC) of each variable was calculated and those that reached the minimum positive magnitudes were determined. For all the analyses carried out, a confidence level of 95% was accepted (significance of p ≤ 0.05). After the intervention, no group reduced significantly their body fat index. Only the GA obtained statistically significant improvements in the variables DMO (+6.9%) and T-Score (-18.6%) of Ward's triangle, and CMO (+5.1%), DMO (+1.4%) and T-Score (-12%) of the total hip. Respect to the upper limbs, both the GT and the GA obtained significant improvements, both at the intra-group level and with respect to the CG, but not between experimental groups, in resistance strength (GT = +74.7%; GA = +71.8 %) and isometric force (GT = +68.3%; GA = +78.1%), while only GA obtained significant improvements in isokinetic force (+29.2% at 180° / s and +39.7% at 60° / s). Respect to the lower limbs, the two groups obtained statistically significant improvements in endurance strength (GT = +110.2%; GA = +95.7%), isometric strength (GT = +103.1%; GA = +93.2%) and isokinetic strength (GT = +17.1% at 180 ° / s and +12.2% at 60° / s; GA = +24.3% at 180° / s and +21.4% at 60° / s), with considerable differences between both groups and the CG, but not among them with the exception of leg resistance strength (p = 0.018). The two experimental groups obtained significant improvements in the four static equilibrium tests (ROA: GT = -34% and GA = -48.1%; ROC: GT = -44.1% and GA = -52.8%; RGA: GT = -50.7% and GA = -45.8%; RGC: GT = -53.7% and GA = -47.2%), in agility and dynamic balance (GT = -27%; GA = -24.6%), and in endurance (GT = +14.2%; GA = +11.7%). However, despite the significant differences related to CG, there was no difference between them. Finally, and despite the fact that there were no significant differences between the experimental groups, only the GA significantly improved in all the well-being variables, both in those that are included in physical health (SG = +25.7%; FF = +22.1%; RF = +41.5%; DC = +41.7%), as in those pertaining to mental health (RE = +47.5%; FS = +13.2%; VT = + 30.5%; SM = +16.2%), and including the annual self-evaluation (+78.1%), while the GT only improved significantly in the variables that correspond to physical health (SG = +23.1%; FF = +10.3%; RF = +13%; DC = +20.9%) and the annual self-evaluation (+33.4%). In conclusion, the present study demonstrates that strength training, with elastic materials and carried out in the aquatic environment, is a good resource to improve body composition, motor performance and well-being in older women. At the same time, it advances that a strength training in the aquatic environment with a rigid control at a methodological level and focused on power, could be a more effective strategy to increase the isokinetic strength of the extremities, and to improve or maintain health bone in this group. However, longer studies are needed to be able to definitively confirm the unpublished results obtained in the present study.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7046662367
Cites: 661
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10