The "european refugee crisis" through a media lens. A cross-national study into press representations of displaced people combining corpus linguistics and argumentation analysis
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The aim of the investigation is to contribute to the field of research on \ndiscourses surrounding the “European refugee crisis” by exploring how people \nmigrating from Asia and Africa to Europe between 2015 and 2018 were represented \nin British, Polish, and Spanish newspapers. To this end, it applies a triangulation of \ntwo methodologies, argumentation analysis and corpus linguistics, to a corpus of \npress articles of over six million tokens. \nThe investigation departs from the assumption that a study of news should \naccount for the issues involved in its creation and reception in the given historical \nand sociopolitical context. Hence, it first explores the relationship between media \nexposure and the audiences' perception of the world as well as sheds some light on \nthe factors influencing media message programming. Next, it looks at the historical \nand sociopolitical processes which might have contributed to shaping the present-day \nresponses to immigration of the three discourse communities under the \ninvestigation. Investigating these aspects is considered to be a complementary source \nof hypotheses and insights which might help illuminate and support findings of the \nsubsequent discourse analysis. \nThe analysis follows several steps. First, tools associated with corpus \nlinguistics are employed to conduct a collocation analysis of the highest-frequency \nterms denoting the displaced people, a wordlist analysis, and a more detailed \nexamination of the most prominent trends revealed as a result of the preceding steps, \nusing concordance and collocation analyses. Second, an analysis of argumentation is \nconducted on a downsampled portion of the corpus. Third, a special analytical \nprocedure is adopted to systematically retrieve and examine migration metaphors \nwhich are common in the corpus. \nThe results show that the 2015-2018 migrations were predominantly \nconceptualised in terms of a crisis for Europe, whereas the displaced people tended to \nbe discursively deprived of the right to seek asylum via a wide range of delegitimising \nlinguistic strategies. This overarching trend is largely consistent across the three \nlanguage subcorpora, with some variation in the frequencies of its particular \nlinguistic realisations. Similarly, while both main analytical approaches point towards \nthis general conclusion, they sometimes differ in the emphasis they put on specific \nfindings, or contribute findings which are in line with the general picture, but which \nhave not been observed using the other methodology. This provides evidence of the \nusefulness of the methodological triangulation applied to this analysis. The thesis \nconcludes with a discussion of the implications of the way in which the newspapers of \nPoland, Spain, and the United Kingdom construe migrations and their principal \nprotagonists, particularly with respect to its impact on the safety and well-being of \nthe displaced people.
Author: Zawadzka Paluektau, Natalia
Language: English
Subfield: Linguistics and Language
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7047307973
