Novel Experimental and Modelling Approaches for the Risk Assessment of Perfluoroalkyl Acids (PFAAs)
Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) are a group of anthropogenic chemicals, widely used for many industrial and commercial purposes. The extremely strong C-F bond provides PFASs with high chemical and thermal stability. Consequently, PFASs are persistent, bioaccumulative and ubiquitously present in environmental matrices worldwide. Under environmental conditions, through changes of the non-fluorinated parts of a molecule, PFAS precursors can be transformed into perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs), regarded as their final transformation product. PFAAs are acidic surfactants, whose properties principally differ depending on their perfluoroalkyl chain length and their terminal polar group. Short-chain PFAAs are widely employed as alternatives for the regulated and restricted long-chain PFAAs, based on the assumption of lower bioaccumulation potential and toxicity in animals. However, they are as persistent as their long-chain homologues, highly soluble, less sorptive to solids, very mobile with water and highly bioaccumulative in plants. The aim of this research thesis is addressing the data and research gaps to assist ecological and human health risk assessment of the perfluoroalkyl acids, with a special focus on their short-chain alternatives. PFAAs exhibit an untypical behavior when compared to other groups of neutral organic pollutants. Their affinity for proteins and phospholipid membranes makes the common risk assessment approaches, mainly relying on the partitioning in storage lipids, inapplicable. Hence, the objectives of this thesis were to address data gaps and provide new insights regarding the fate and behavior of PFAAs, from 1) the ecological risk assessment point of view and 2) in terrestrial (agronomic) ecosystems, as the main pathway of PFAAs into the terrestrial food webs. An additional focus was put on the major PFAS contamination case in the Veneto Region, Northern Italy. The first part of the thesis concentrates on existing ecological risk assessment methodologies and proposes a new method for deriving the ecological risk thresholds of micro-contaminants, which is applied to two legacy long-chain PFAAs, PFOA and PFOS, two short chain PFAAs, PFBA and PFBS, as their common substitutes, and two well studied emerging contaminants (LAS and triclosan) for comparison. The newly proposed methodology is based on the ecological and chemicals fate model AQUATOX (USEPA), applied to aquatic ecosystem of the Po, the largest Italian river with a significant pollutants burden (including PFAAs). By the use of AQUATOX, ecological relationships between organisms were included as well as the sublethal effects of chemicals, resulting in indirect toxicity effects leading to ecological threshold values that usually differed from the ones derived by regulated methodologies. The second part of the thesis concentrates on simulating the transfer of nine PFAAs from pre-contaminated soil and irrigation water to a model crop, the red chicory, by a combination of greenhouse plant uptake experiments, laboratory soil-sorption tests and plant uptake models. The experimental set-up includes various exposure media: soil and water, separately and in synergy, as well as a soilless (hydroponic) system. The experimental results emphasized the significance of irrigation water as exposure media, leading to a potentially higher plant uptake of PFAAs, and the uncertainty in the use of hydroponically derived plant uptake factors for risk assessment. The semi-empirical plant uptake model for PFAAs, based on inter-compartmental PFAAs distribution in red chicory, soil-water partitioning and plant-specific measured data was successfully applied to other crops and provided new mechanistic insights into the complex uptake processes. Finally, a modelling framework consisting of crop models connected to simple pharmacokinetic models for farm animals, was developed and applied in the dietary exposure of the Veneto population to long- and short-chain PFAAs.
Author: Gredelj, Andrea
Institution: University of Padua
Language: English
Subfield: Environmental Chemistry
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
Award: G8705268757
OpenAlex ID: W7049373680
