Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The study conducted in Manuscript 1 investigated the relationships and dynamics among key policy, informational, and financial actors regarding their influences on the characterization of climate change in the Texas K-12 science content standards. Previous studies have investigated the impact of ambiguous and exclusionary climate change content in the science curriculum, but few have considered the preponderance of policy networks and their role regarding climate change in science standards. Using the lens of policy network theory, a network ethnographic approach was used to analyze policy documents and video recordings of Texas State Board of Education meetings related to the portrayal of climate change in the Texas science standards. Relational data was collected and used to construct sociograms to visualize and analyze policy network structure and identify critical actors. To that end, the findings are a detailed account of an orchestrated effort led by critical actors in the policy networks to insert fossil fuel propaganda into the science standards by gaining appointments to key positions responsible for writing content standards, posing as climate experts during public testimony, and by providing explicit recommendations for specific student expectations. The findings of this study suggested that surrogate organizations representing the fossil fuel industry (The Texas Energy Council, Texas Natural Gas Foundation, and the Texas Public Policy Foundation) engaged in a systemic campaign with industry-funded elected officials to distort the causes of climate change, censor the effects of fossil fuels, and misrepresent renewable energy sources in Texas science standards. The surrogate organizations directly engaged propagandizing the science standards were commended by Texas regulatory agencies (The Texas Railroad Commission, The Texas Land Commission) and by the Texas Oil and Gas Associations, whose board members include high ranking officials from the nation’s largest oil producers, including ExxonMobil, Shell, BP, Chevron, all of whom have previously been cited for promoting climate change misinformation. This study reaffirmed that policy networks are not passive entities but powerful agents, thus contributing to a broader discourse on the role of policy networks in shaping education and calling for more comprehensive and network-informed approaches to education policy research. Manuscript 2 examined how the Texas Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for middle grades supported climate literacy, as defined by the Principles of Climate Literacy (PCL) conceptual framework by the US Global Change Research Program. In 2022, the IPCC released the sixth Assessment Report and found that in the US, vested interests have generated rhetoric and misinformation undermining climate science. Further stating that rhetoric and misinformation have contributed to misperceptions that have delayed climate policy and action. However, studies have found that climate literacy may protect the public against climate change misinformation, finding it to be most effective when acquired during adolescence. Furthermore, studies have found that state-adopted, standards-aligned curricular materials like textbooks are integral to science instruction, with most teachers relying on them as an authoritative source of information. However, there is a lack of research investigating the role of standards-aligned curriculum materials in shaping students' climate literacy. This study employed a deductive content analysis (DCA) to analyze 12 pre-approved textbook samples aligned to the newly adopted science TEKS for 8th-grade science in Texas. Pre-approved samples are a useful resource for assessing curricular content and alignment in Texas. Before the curriculum is approved for adoption, publishers must submit a complete electronic copy of their instructional materials to the Texas Education Agency. All samples must appear and function exactly as the final product. Texas requires all student-facing materials to include at least 50% of the TEKS. Therefore, pre-approved samples provide insight into the student-facing climate change content resulting from the newly adopted science standards. According to the findings of the DCA, most pre-approved TEKS-aligned curricula included content related to the overarching PCL themes. However, the content coverage depth depended on the overlap between the PCL and the TEKS. Content regarding the mechanics of climate, a construct included in the PCL and TEKs, was robust and comprehensive. Conversely, content included in the PCL but not the TEKS, such as the scientific consensus of climate change, the negative impacts of fossil fuels, and the consequences for humans and ecosystems, were superficial if addressed at all, in the curriculum. Additionally, content included in the TEKS but not the PCL, like hurricane formation, also received less coverage in the curriculum. Therefore, this study suggested that science standards more aligned with PCL may be more likely to foster climate literacy. While publishers may provide some mediation for standards lacking climate literacy constructs by including content beyond that included in state standards, they may do so only superficially. Manuscript 3, a policy white paper, described efforts by the fossil fuel industry to undermine the public perception of climate change and influence policy through rhetoric and misinformation. The paper identified the parallels between well-documented climate change misinformation presented in the media through direct advertisements, journalistic 'bothsideism,' organized social media campaigns, and recent attempts to install fossil fuel propaganda into science curricula in Texas by targeting policymakers and teachers. Because climate change misinformation harms students' understanding of climate science and hinders society's progress toward climate action, this study emphasized the critical role of educators and policymakers in addressing issues of climate change misinformation in curricular materials. This manuscript provides a brief overview of the climate change countermovement and the politicization resulting in higher rates of climate change denial among elected conservatives. It also provides specific examples of propagandized climate change educational content developed for children produced through conservative organizations and media with ties to the fossil fuel industry (i.e., Heartland Institute, PragerU, CO2 Coalition). Furthermore, this policy white paper describes the risk and vulnerability of children in Texas, who, through systematic oppression, geography, and policy decisions, are more likely to suffer the effects of climate change. In addition, this paper outlines the orchestrated efforts to censor and deny Texas children access to an education aligned with the scientific consensus regarding the causes and effects of climate change and provides specific examples of fossil fuel propaganda and misinformation promoted during state board of education meetings, that resulted in Texas science standards. Finally, the white paper makes recommendations for action; most paramount is recognizing that the fossil fuel industry, through surrogate organizations, is influencing scientifically naïve policymakers, intentionally distorting science, and censoring public education to mislead children for the economic benefit of fossil fuel companies. Denying children access to information necessary to achieve climate literacy impedes their ability to meaningfully participate in decisions about their environment, increasing their vulnerability to environmental hazards that negatively impact their health, economic standing, and ability to thrive. The denial of meaningful participation in an act of environmental injustice (as defined by the US Department of Environmental Justice) would be an avenue through which policymakers could respond. Through more immediate action, educators and education leaders should carefully consider and scrutinize science curricula to ensure they are not unknowingly placing their students at greater risk and perpetuating anti-science propaganda.
Author: Miller, Jocelyn
Institution: Texas Tech University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Climate action
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7051686639
