Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This study explored Australian Indigenous perspectives of the concept of success. Qualitative audio interviews with semi-structured questions and a conversational approach adhered to the Indigenous research paradigm. Participants were provided with an opportunity to share their views. The welcoming nature of Indigenous communities as well as other rewarding experiences for myself were echoed during this study and examples were reported. A local Indigenous individual noticed that Indigenous perspectives of success often differed from many common ideas within a mainstream Western society. This was confirmed by the comments of eleven research participants. The literature review highlighted an earlier literary emphasis on problems rather than the positive aspects of Indigenous communities. Investigating stories related to success was an attempt to avoid adding more unpleasant material that was present in the literature. The literature review empathised with Dennis Foley researching Indigenous success in entrepreneurism and Jeannie Herbert examining success in higher education, followed by an examination of the meaning of success. This study sought generalised community views of success, rather than success in one field. Most data for this research were collected in the central Gippsland region, supplemented with three interviews at Circular Quay in Sydney. All participants indicated they lived a suburban lifestyle; 29 qualitative interviews were conducted, with 26 rated as useful and transcribed verbatim. All interviews satisfied the ethical clearance requirements and followed the advice of key authors arguing for decolonisation when completing modern research. Interviews were analysed by employing grounded theory thematic analysis, using an interpretive method with elements of deductive reasoning. Five observed themes were classified as general comments about success: success is different, success is available to all, difficulty discussing success, determination, and creativity or spirituality. Five themes were classed as definition of success: family support, contribution to community, achieving goals, happiness and continuing culture. A discussion of links between themes argued the broad range of views of participants evinced communal implications for success as well as a devaluation of materialism. Other links included the support for cultural traditions and the inadequacy of common Western definitions of the concept of success. The analysis acknowledged the overlaps between cultures that can exist when comparing Indigenous with mainstream cultures, especially when recognising individual differences. Literature identified concurred with findings from this study. Research limits included sampling restrictions and a limited time frame. Suggestions for further research included extra research be completed in more regions in Australia with more women, a broader age range and more cultural groups. Differences were observed regarding the concept of success for Indigenous individuals when compared with more common mainstream Western views as well appreciating the value of continuing the culture were two examples of the claims made by most participants. Therefore, the findings of the research resulted in recommendations for policymakers, educationists, academic researchers and the general community to converse with Indigenous groups and increase the understanding of the views for the meaning of the concept of success.
Author: Hamilton, Ian
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funder: Australian Government
OpenAlex ID: W7052537417
