Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Bringing together studies of film, scholarship on collective practices, new materialist positions on agencies of the more-than-human and decolonial positions on knowledge practices, this doctoral thesis is an empirical investigation of the cinematic practices of community filmmakers in contemporary Indonesia, as well as a theoretical contemplation on the social-transformative potential of cinematic epistemologies. Komunitas film (film community/ies) mushroomed in Indonesia after political reformation in 1998 along with the availability of digital filmmaking technology. Today, mobile screenings and community filmmaking are omnipresent phenomenon in Indonesia with hundreds of komunitas film all over the archipelago, who make, screen and discuss short films. An Indonesian film activist once told me: ‘if you want to understand Indonesia you have to watch short films’ (see also Engchuan 2020, 12). In Indonesian film communities, films are deeply rooted in the social experience of the filmmakers and made to trigger discussions on local social issues during the screening events. From this observation a series of question arises: why and how do they engage in cinematic practice to act upon local social issues? Or in other words: what are the conditions, modalities, affordances and effects of cinematic epistemologies? Attending to these questions, this dissertation offers a window onto the modes and conditions of cinematic practices within Indonesian film communities, as well as a local and situated commentary on the social and cultural circumstances the films depict. It is a project of looking at social phenomena through films, together with filmmakers. The answers, as I will suggest throughout the publications as well as this framework text, pivots around the notion of togetherness (kebersamaan), a way of being in the world that is grounded in a relational ontology. In essence, this is a thesis on how cinematic practices come from togetherness, are performed in togetherness and aim at cultivating togetherness. Therefore, I will conceptualize and explore togetherness, its constituents (which include the more-than-human), its moral grammar (which is often related with the Indonesian notion of gotong royong), its actualization, instituting and cultivation — through cinematic practices. Theoretically and conceptually, togetherness calls for an inquiry of forms of relatedness rather than entities (filmmakers, censors, films). Komunitas film should not be taken for granted as an existing empirical unit and is perhaps better described as a relational process and a mode of collectivity. Drawing on empirical work, as well as scholarship that re-defines technology as a relation, and conceives of agency as distributed rather than located in an individual human, this cumulative dissertation looks at the practices of komunitas film as situated epistemic assemblages. Scrutinizing the film as an object and analytical category, I conceptualize cinematic practices of making, screening and discussing film as relational-processual assemblages of collective agency. Through such a processual, relational assemblage perspective, I am following Yuk Hui’s imperative to conceive of multiple cosmotechnics ‘which are different from each other not simply functionally and aesthetically, but also ontologically and cosmologically’ (2016, xiii), re-mapping the dominant technological development narrative with a story from Indonesia. Departing from a processual-relational assemblage perspective, related questions emerge: what are the affordances of cinematic languages and what is the collective agency of cinematic practices and the cinematic spaces and epistemologies they produce? Using a variety of anthropological methods, which have been adapted to the theoretical and conceptual assemblage perspective and developed over the course of this research, this research derives arguments from empirical, theoretical and dialogical archives: participant observation on film sets and at film screenings, ethnographically informed film analysis as well as para-site situations of thinking nearby — spaces where analytical propositions were discussed and created in dialogue with film practitioners. The individual publications examine four short films from the environment of komunitas film that address a variety of situated social and environmental issues: ON FRIDAY NOON (2016, dir. Luhki Herwanayogi) on queer struggles for self-determination against the backdrop of increasingly orthodox interpretations of Islam, SEORANG KAMBING (A GOAT) (2017 dir. Tunggul Banjaransari) on water scarcity and land conflicts in the Gunung Kidul mountains, SAPU ANGIN (WINDSWEPT) (2017 dir. Cahyo Prayogo) on classed urbanization processes in Surabaya and SPECTACULAR HEALING (2019 dir. Lifepatch) a two channel video on ‘Lifepatch’s ongoing research related to colonialism of the Batak tribe in North Sumatra’ (Lifepatch 2021, np). Conceiving of these films not as representational objects, but as bridges into cinematic assemblages and situated socio-environmental clusters, this research investigates komunitas film as alternative pedagogies that entail both social and cinematic spaces. Films, here are nodes in grander processes of collective knowledge creation and articulation. Situated within a broader analysis of epistemological conventions, each of the cases discussed in this doctoral thesis constitutes and illustrates alternative infrastructures and modes of collective knowledge production — in tune with what Santos (2016, 2018) has called the epistemologies of the South. Epistemology here is social and relational, knowledge is not imposed as a detached object but negotiated in dialogue, it is a process. Bringing together a complex empirical and dialogical understanding of the co-constitutive relationship between cinematic and social spaces, with the notion of togetherness and critical decolonial positions on knowledge politics, this doctoral thesis concludes that cinematic practices enact a political gesture, which lies in cultivating the grounds for care—as a social and relational configuration. The transformative potential of cinematic epistemologies lies in not merely suggesting or depicting but enacting and performing alternatives ways of knowing and being in the world — in togetherness.
Author: Engchuan, Rosalia Namsai
Language: English
Topic: Cinema and Media Studies
Subfield: Visual Arts and Performing Arts
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7056602770
