Work

Imersão e Distanciamento em Psicoterapia para a Depressão

Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In the last decade, immersion (egocentric perspective) and distancing (observer perspective) on negative experiences have been the subject of increasing interest in research given their potential for adaptive as well as maladaptive reflection on these experiences. Research in this area has been mainly conducted in experimental/laboratory context, considering distancing, as opposed to immersion, as a beneficial perspective in the reflection on experiences. Departing from these results, indications about its advantages in psychotherapy have been raised, namely in the reduction of the emotional arousal of negative emotions and in the reconstruction experiences. However, these studies do not seem to fit in the requirements and characteristics of a therapeutic process. A synchronous view of the immersed and distanced perspectives does not meet the concept of change in psychotherapy, more precisely with respect to the dynamic and integrated transformation of processes throughout treatment. Moreover, assessing the adaptability of the perspective through the level of well-being, namely through the emotional arousal of negative emotions, is not consistent with the positive and important role of emotional involvement in the promotion of clinical change. Thus, the present dissertation proposed to clarify the role of immersion and distancing in psychotherapy in the treatment of depression. With this objective, four studies were carried out with a more flexible and longitudinal approach on these phenomena, framed within process-outcome research. Specifically, study 1 aimed to analyze the evolution of immersion and distancing during the therapeutic resolution of a problematic experience, the relationship between immersion/distancing and depressive symptoms, and the relationship between these perspectives and emotional arousal. Study 2 aimed to assess how and when immersion and distancing may be useful/harmful to clinical change, comparing the evolution of these perspectives throughout therapy and its relationship with symptoms in good and poor outcome cases. Study 3 intended to analyze the relationship between the evolution of immersion/distancing and the assimilation of problematic experiences, as well as the association between these perspectives and the different stages of therapeutic change. Finally, study 4 aimed to assess the relationship between flexibility between perspectives in the intermediate phase of therapy and depressive symptoms at the end of treatment. Methodologically, two case studies with good-outcome cases (studies 1 and 3) and two sample studies with good and poor outcome cases (studies 2 and 4) were carried out. The analyzed cases were selected from the ISMAI Depression Study and were followed in contrasting therapies, namely cognitive-behavioral therapy and emotion focused therapy. Several process measures were used, such as the Measure of Immersed and Distanced Speech to assess immersion and distancing; Client Emotional Arousal Scale-III to assess emotional arousal; Assimilation of Problematic Experiences Scale to assess therapeutic change levels. Flexibility was determined by the number and magnitude of transitions between perspectives. The Beck Depression Inventory-II and the Outcome Questionnaire-10.2 were used as outcome measures. The results of the studies revealed an evolution pattern of immersion/distancing associated with clinical change characterized by greater initial immersion followed by a substantial increase of distancing (studies 1, 2 and 3). These results point to the benefits of increasing distancing in achieving better levels of well-being in terms of symptomatology (studies 1 and 2) and more positive emotional states (study 1), as well as in creating insight and effective problem solving (study 3). Conversely, stability in the reflection pattern characterized by high immersion throughout the process appears to be harmful (study 2). However, these observations do not invalidate the importance of immersion in psychotherapy. Initial immersion may be useful in overcoming avoidance states and in raising awareness and clarification of the problem. Moreover, the positive role of immersion also extended to a high level of change, namely on the application of new understandings to solve the problem (study 3). Results also revealed that greater flexibility between immersion and distancing in the intermediate phase of therapy appears to be associated with better outcomes in terms of depressive symptoms at the end of treatment (study 4). Altogether, this dissertation stresses the importance of both perspectives – immersion and distancing - in psychotherapy for depression, assuming them as coordinated and dynamic mechanisms, integrated in the process of change.
Author: Barbosa, Eunice Liliana Dias
Language: Portuguese
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7057105691
Cites: 181
Cited by:
Related to: 10