How AI images and human-created digital art are evaluated and affected by attribution knowledge
Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Artificial intelligence (AI) has spread into different sectors and is seeing fast developments in the field of text-to-image generation. Its rapid evolution and increased usage raise a myriad of questions. For instance, how will people perceive images generated by a machine compared to art created by a human being? Previous research done within the field of AI generation ranges from how people respond to its images in relation to human-created art in different settings to the role that attribution knowledge - the knowledge of who has created an image - plays in its reception. Further areas explored are how perceived values affect the evaluation of artwork as well as how AI generators generate their images and the risks that come with diffusion models. This study investigates a) how individuals (both artists and non-artists) evaluate AI images and human-created digital art, b) whether they can accurately identify AI images from human-created digital art, and c) if attribution knowledge plays a role in their reception of the AI images and human-created digital art. In order to examine how people evaluate AI images and human-created digital art, and what may affect their evaluation a survey was conducted. In the survey participants were given representational art either created by a human being or produced by the AI-generator Stable Diffusion and were then given different tasks. The results suggested bias against AI-generated images, seemingly rooted in the AI-generators' construction and its ethical implications. Furthermore, the results suggested an existing belief that AI images either have or lack some inherent quality, being either visible tell-tale signs and/or something philosophical, which should set them apart from human-created artwork. Despite this belief, the result points towards difficulty in deducing whether the creator of the image is human or machine.
Authors: Khan, Maryam, Näsström, Julia
Institution: KTH Royal Institute of Technology
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7057107071
