Work

Intra and inter-annual patterns in Lake Yojoa, Honduras: disentangling biogeochemical drivers of a tropical monomictic lake ecosystem

Year: 2022
Type: article
Abstract: Since its inception, limnology has been disproportionately focused on temperate ecosystems, leaving tropical lakes underrepresented in the contemporary limnological literature.Beyond the relative paucity of published studies, knowledge of tropical lake ecology is limited by the inapplicability of various veins of temperate research to tropical lake ecosystems.This disconnect is largely due to higher annual temperatures and, in the case of monomictic lakes, the presence of a persistent, warm, anoxic hypolimnion during stratified months.These warm (> 20 C) and anoxic waters define tropical lake biogeochemistry via anaerobic metabolisms operating without the thermal constraints observed at higher latitudes (with the exception of high elevation tropical lakes).This dissertation builds on recent advances in tropical limnology by providing new insight into the foundational processes underpinning the ecology of tropical monomictic lakes.The following chapters combine a literature review (Chapter 1) with an in-depth study of Lake Yojoa, Honduras (Chapters 2-5) to explore tropical lake biogeochemistry, with a particular focus on nitrogen.Despite mounting evidence that phytoplankton in tropical lakes experience an array of limiting nutrients, references to low latitude lakes being predominantly nitrogen limited remain common in the literature.To assess the current understanding of nutrient limitation regimes in tropical lakes I performed a literature review to summarize observations of nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and colimitation in the collected studies.I also identified common drivers of tropical nutrient limitation regimes.I found that while N is a key limiting nutrient in some of the reviewed studies, it was not the dominant limiting nutrient in the majority of reviewed lakes.Rather, tropical lakes exhibited a diversity of nutrient limitation and there was often considerable heterogeneity of the dominant limiting nutrient within an individual lake.This iii heterogeneity was driven largely by seasonal patterns of water column stratification and precipitation, land use and land cover (LULC), and the interaction of these characteristics with lake morphology.Similar to many of the lakes identified in the literature review, Lake Yojoa experienced intra-annual nutrient limitation heterogeneity, being N and P colimited during the stratified months and P limited during the mixed water column phase.Over the last forty years , Lake Yojoa has seen increased watershed development as well as the introduction of a large net-pen Tilapia farm, resulting in a dramatic reduction in seasonal water clarity, increased trophic state, and altered nutrient dynamics, shifting Lake Yojoa from an oligotrophic (low productivity) to mesotrophic (moderate productivity) ecosystem.To assess the changes that have occurred in Lake Yojoa as well as putative drivers for those changes, I compared Secchi depth, dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN), and total phosphorus (TP) concentrations at continuous semi-monthly intervals for the three years between 1979-1983 and again at continuous 16-day intervals from 2018-2020.Between those two periods, I observed the loss of a clear water phase that previously occurred in the months when the water column was fully mixed.Seasonal peaks in DIN coincident with mixing suggest that an enhanced accumulation of ammonium in the hypolimnion during stratification, and release to the epilimnion with mixing maintained high algal abundance and subsequently low Secchi depth during what was previously the clear water phase.In November of 2020, Hurricanes Eta and Iota made landfall near the Nicaragua-Honduras border, inundating the region with a large amount of late-season precipitation.To understand the impact of such storms on inland aquatic ecosystems, I compared two years of continuous monitoring in Lake Yojoa using one year prior to and one year following Hurricanes Eta and Iota.The storms resulted in an increase in Secchi depth and a decrease in algal abundance directly following the hurricanes and a lower-than-average accumulation of hypolimnetic nutrients from the onset of stratification until mixus the next November (2021).However, following annual water column turnover in 2021, epilimnetic nutrient concentrations returned to (and in some cases exceeded) pre-hurricane levels, presumably due to an internal release of ammonium previously stored in the sediments.Lake Yojoa's response suggests that trophic state was resilient to the disturbance imposed by the two hurricanes because of decades of nutrient enrichment and iv super saturation of the lake's sediments.This indicates that ongoing eutrophication in Lake Yojoa will not likely be easily mitigated by decreasing allochthonous nutrient loading and may require years to decades to recover the trophic state observed in the early 1980's.The work described above highlights the need to better define nutrient dynamics of warm anoxic hypolimnions, not just surface water nutrient concentrations, to more completely understand the mechanisms of environmental change in monomictic tropical lakes.To identify the dominant N transformation pathways that likely drive the observed dynamics, I combined geochemical data, thermophysical structure measurements and metatranscriptomic analysis of the water column microbiome.I sampled at two depths (1 and 16 m) in June 2021, when Lake Yojoa was stratified, and again in January 2022, when the water column was mixed.Within the dereplicated MAG database (n=552), 335 different lineages were identified.Microbial communities were significantly different across seasons and, in June, between depths.N metabolism gene expression was highest in the June hypolimnion.Across the three sampled locations, we found nrfA expression was upregulated relative to other N metabolism genes, suggesting that dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) is a likely mechanism for inorganic N accumulation during stratification, in addition to the sediment nutrient release identified in Chapter 3.Finally, to test the efficacy of using a remote sensing approach to expand the temporal resolution of this research, I adapted an existing machine learning model which uses remotely sensed variables to estimate Secchi depth and chlorophyll a.The model was trained on data from Chapters 2 and 3 using in situ observations from 2018 to 2020 and then used to estimate pelagic surface conditions in 2021.While the chlorophyll a model performed poorly, the Secchi depth model was comparable to other published remote sensing models and captured the clear water phase following Hurricanes Eta and Iota discussed in Chapter 3. In addition to exploring the opportunity of expanding the current temporal resolution of research efforts presented in this dissertation, this final chapter demonstrates how existing remote sensing models can be applied to new systems and developed using data from short term continuous monitoring efforts in order to create longer term data products, both to the benefit of future research, and local collaborators and stakeholders.v Though largely focused on a single ecosystem (Lake Yojoa), by layering multiple approaches, the research presented here leverages a unique historical dataset from an under-studied region (Central America) to generate new insight into foundational biogeochemistry of tropical lakes.By identifying changes in Lake Yojoa's intra-annual geochemical patterns which corresponded with observable interannual ecosystem-scale increases in primary productivity, we were able to hypothesize the primary mechanistic drivers.The natural experiment created by Hurricanes Eta and Iota provided further evidence for these initial hypotheses (which were ultimately tested by analyzing Lake Yojoa's microbial metatranscriptome) and confirmed that disturbance response is identifiable through remote monitoring of trophic state.Taken together, this work demonstrates the complex relationship between nutrient loading and physical structure in monomictic tropical lakes and illustrates the need to consider the critical role that the hypolimnion plays in governing whole ecosystem function.Whereas the deepest waters in lakes are often overlooked in ecosystems where low temperatures limit microbial metabolism and prevent rapid nutrient transformations, warm anoxic hypolimnions may prove to be the dominant driver of the overall characteristics of tropical lake ecosystems.viACKNOWLEDGEMENTS There is a near infinite list of people who have made this dissertation possible.While I could go on for pages, I'll try to consolidate it to the following: Thank you first and foremost to Ed, for your mentorship, compassion, and trust.Thank you, Kelly, Matt, and Amy for all the support and guidance.A big thanks to Juan Carlos, and everyone else at AMUPROLAGO.Without your work, this research would have been impossible.Thank you, Reb, Kris, and Guy for all of your wisdom and help in the lab and Mikayla for so much of your time.Thank you, Casey for helping me keep everything within the error bars.Thank you to Jennifer
Authors: Fadum, Jemma Mazuri, author, Hall, Ed, advisor, Wrighton, Kelly, committee member, Ross, Matt, committee member, Burgin, Amy, committee member
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7057133257
FWCI:
Cites: 232
Cited by:
Related to: 10