Work

If we wish to hold on to the welfare of our country – An exploration of discourses concerning transport automation in the Finnish transport governance culture

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In recent years, perhaps no other technological phenomenon in the field of transport has attracted more attention in both public and academic discourses than transport automation. Advocates believe that transport automation technologies will make mobility systems safer, more efficient, more environmentally sustainable and more equitable. Conversely, sceptics suspect that these technologies may simply deepen the lock-in to the unsustainable system of automobility. At the locus of this development are the central governance actors whose responsibility is to ensure societally desirable outcomes. The culture that governance networks uphold is an often overlooked aspect in transport policy studies. Nonetheless, governance cultures play a major part in how governing is done in practice. Similarly to how national cultures sustain patterns of interaction between people, governance cultures steer governance actors to operate in locally distinct ways. Therefore, the exploration of the different elements of a governance culture can provide answers to why governance actors do what they do. Moreover, such exploration offers the possibility to critique and contest the fundamental premises of governance. As such, understanding governance cultures is vital for breaking path dependencies that might result in undesirable futures. This article-based dissertation explores the Finnish transport governance culture through discourses concerning the governance of transport automation in Finland. Paper I analyses the publications of central governance actors – i.e., the official governance discourse – with the Critical Discourse Analysis approach. Paper II explores the informal discourses that exist in the governance network through semi-structured interviews. Paper III utilises the Q-methodology for identifying contradicting and aligning governance ideologies that exist in the governance network. The document analysis illustrated how transport automation is connected to numerous positive implications in the official discourse. Yet, it is often unclear what the authors mean by transport automation. The interviews revealed that the governance actors broadly agree with the ideas of the official discourse; however, they also illustrated that more sceptical views and nuanced deliberation exist in the governance network. The Q-methodology process confirmed that there is broad contestation concerning the governance of emerging mobility technologies in the network. This contestation might relate to the inherent conflict of political ideologies that exists in all democracies. Alternatively, the contestation may stem from recent changes in the Finnish transport governance culture that concern the enablement of technological innovation in the sector. Combining the insights from the three studies, this dissertation presents an overview of the cultural elements that have affected the governance of transport automation in Finland.
Author: Olin, Janne
Language: English
Subfield: Transportation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7057345623
Cites: 187
Cited by:
Related to: 10