Work

Niet op je plek zitten: Persoon-omgeving fit als een bondige manier om pesten op het werk te begrijpen.

Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: While scholars have described workplace bullying as a multi-causal phenomenon in which person-related and work-related factors are closely intertwined, very limited empirical research has investigated this. In reply, this dissertation contributes to the literature in four ways. First, the multi-causal idea is operationalized and tested in a parsimonious way by introducing Person-Environment Fit (PE-fit); being the employee's perceived congruence between his/her personal characteristics and those of the work environment. Second, the important work-environmental dimensions in explaining workplace bullying - job, work group, and organization - are defined and studied in line with PE-fit by implementing Person-Job fit (PJ-fit), Person-Group fit (PG-fit), and Person-Organization fit (PO-fit) in the subsequent studies. Third, both psychological strain and interpersonal conflict are investigated as explanatory mechanisms in the association between low perceived fit with the work environment and workplace bullying. Finally, these associations are tested for both exposure to (i.e. target) and enactment of (i.e. perpetrator) workplace bullying. Three studies addressed these aims. In Study 1, we built on the Three Way Model of workplace bullying (Baillien et al., 2009) in developing an overall model linking PE-fit to workplace bullying. Specifically, we hypothesize that PE-fit, defined as three different fit dimensions of PJ-fit, PG-fit and PO-fit, are negatively associated with both exposure to and enactment of workplace bullying. We argue that these associations are explained through strain as well as conflict. In all, our cross-sectional study confirms that PE-fit can be regarded as a parsimonious way of explaining both being a target as a perpetrator of workplace bullying and that strain and conflict could be regarded as mediators. Particularly interesting findings include a low indirect association between low PJ-fit and workplace bullying through strain, and a notably strong association between PG-fit and bullying mostly explained by conflict. In Study 2, we explored whether the low indirect association between low PJ-fit and workplace bullying via strain could be attributed to perceptions of job insecurity. Our results confirmed this idea and show that even when employees are dealing with a low fitting job, the threat of losing this job creates a context in which stress is reinforced, triggering more workplace bullying. In Study 3, we investigated the relationship between low PG-fit and workplace bullying, through strain and conflict, in a 3 wave cross-lagged design. The results confirmed these relationships and consequently revealed that an employee perceiving a low PG-fit may also become the one who enacts bullying as a form of self-defence. Overall, this dissertation showed that (a) PE-fit (PJ-fit, PG-fit and PO-fit) are valuable in explaining workplace bullying, (b) especially PG-fit is associated with workplace bullying and (c) both strain and conflict are explanatory mechanisms, although their effect size depends on the fit dimension. Moreover, (d) both targets and perpetrators seem to be affected by quite similar antecedents, indicating bullying enactment may also be regarded as a response to a weaker position in terms of low PE-fit.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7058446957
Cites: 238
Cited by:
Related to: 10