Responding to Populism: Anti-Populism in the French and British Governments’ Framing of the Gilets Jaunes and Brexit Crises
Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: In the face of crisis, defenders of liberal democratic regimes regularly dismiss popular politics as a populist threat. This thesis is concerned with this defensive liberal response to populism and what it implies for democratic and emancipatory horizons. Embracing an early Laclauian perspective on populism as a conjunctural form of emancipatory struggle and building on a post-Marxist relational and discursive framework, I propose to study this response through the prism of anti-populism. To this end, I redefine populism and anti-populism as competing hegemonic constructions of crisis, alongside institutionalism – traditionally conceived as the ‘other’ of populism – which denies crisis altogether. While populism exposes the crisis ‘of’ a system, requiring radical systemic change, anti-populism underlies discourses attempting to (re)construct the crisis as a crisis ‘in’, manageable through internal revolutions. I apply these logics through a framing and logics analysis on two case studies: the French government’s response to the Gilets jaunes movement in 2018-2019; and the British government’s response to Brexit in 2016-2017. While in both cases, actors in charge of responding to these crises have also been called populists because of their engagement with ‘the people’, the analysis reveals instead their dual reliance on institutionalism and anti-populism – simultaneously defending stability and embracing instability – to manage each event. The presence of anti-populism unveils the contingent and contestable nature of these responses and the ideological forms they take. In each case, the government operates as the key institution attempting to mask such contingency, negotiating the deepening contradictions between a commitment to democracy and to the apolitical order needed to sustain liberal regimes. As liberal-democratic states today increasingly rely on repressive methods to manage these contradictions, I argue that anti-populism, more than populism, threatens democracy.
Author: Ietter, S
Institution: Queen Mary University of London
Language: English
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7061992730
