Social acceptance of school-aged children eligible for special education : examining the influence of child characteristics and type of school placement
Year: 2007
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Social relationships with peers are a major influence on the development and learning of children during the school years and are associated with important long-term outcomes. One important aspect of social relationships is social acceptance, which is the degree to which an individual child is liked and/or disliked by all members of his or her social group. As numerous studies have supported the important influence of early social acceptance on academic achievement, school adjustment, and psychological well-being in adulthood (Kupersmidt, Coie, & Dodge, 1990; Pardini, Barry, Bmih, Lochman, & Wells, 2006), social acceptance has been a central focus of studies examining the social functioning of children. Since many children with disabilities have been found to demonstrate difficulties in developing social relationships (Gresham, 1992; Vaughn, Elbaum, & Shumm) and may lack the cognitive, adaptive, and social skills to successfully interact with peers (Odom et al., 2006), they are a particulmly unique group at risk for poor social relationships. With the federal mandate to include children with special education needs in general education classrooms to the maximum time possible as appropriate, researchers have targeted to investigate the social outcomes of inclusion along with examining the learning gains. Although proponents of inclusion have stressed the social benefits of integrating children with disabilities in general education classrooms, studies examining social outcomes of inclusion have yielded varying results. While some studies have found increases in reciprocal friendships and more frequent peer interactions (e.g., Guralnick, 1999), many others have pointed to unfavorable outcomes including loneliness, frequent rejection, social isolation, and lower acceptance (e.g., Pavri & Luftig, 2000). The current study aimed to further examine the social acceptance of school-aged children having special education eligibility. In doing so, the study aimed to investigate whether or not children's level of peer acceptance is an artifact of various factors, including individual child characteristics (i.e., behaviors, social skills, and intelligence) and type of school placement. The sample consisted of 122 school-aged children who were a part of the NIH-funded Collaborative Family Study conducted at three university sites in Southern California and rural Pennsylvania. The participants were grouped into three school placement groupings based on their type of school placement (i.e., general education, inclusion, or special education setting). Social acceptance, the outcome measure, was measured based on teacher reports on a rating form. Results indicate that children having special education needs experience lower levels of social acceptance compared to their general education peers regardless of type of placement. Furthermore, the students with disabilities in both groupings did not differ in their level of social acceptance indicating that placement alone does not appear to make a difference for their social functioning. Further analyses of the relationship between child characteristics and social acceptance revealed that behavior problems, social skills, and intelligence are significantly related to social outcomes. As children with disabilities in both the Inclusion and Special Education groupings were found to have lower social skills and higher levels of behavior problems as compared to their peers without disabilities, children eligible for special education, irrespective of their placement, become a particular group at-risk for low levels of social acceptance. Finally, a hierarchical regression showed that social skills and problem behaviors have the greatest influence on social acceptance, thus explaining the variance in social acceptance experienced by children in general education placement compared to inclusion and special education placements. As current and previous findings have not been able to provide support for the social benefits of inclusion, the importance of focusing on strengthening social skills and reducing behavior problems for students with disabilities rather than focusing on inclusion in general education classrooms to foster social acceptance and promote positive social outcomes becomes highlighted. Implications for practice and future directions are proposed.
Author: Minassian, Sandra
Institution: California State University, Northridge
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: social acceptance, peer acceptance, children with disabilities, special education eligibility, school placement, inclusive education, general education, special education, child characteristics, social skills, intelligence, peer rejection, teacher ratings, school adjustment, interpersonal relationships, child behavior problems, academic performance, psychological well-being, loneliness, reciprocal friendship, peer interaction
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7062059824
