Year: 2022
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Foster placement breakdown, wherein foster parents request the removal of their foster children, is detrimental to foster children and is linked to increased behavioral problems, poor academic growth, and housing instability later in life.This study utilized rational choice theory to explore how child (age, gender, race, health, behavior, history of sexual abuse victimization), foster family (number of caregivers, income), and case (TPR status) characteristics affect foster parents' decision-making processes regarding placement breakdown.A secondary analysis was performed on data from the National Survey on Child and Adolescent Well-being II (NSCAW II), a longitudinal study that followed 5,873 children from 83 counties in 30 states, to determine the extent to which child, foster family, and case characteristics are correlated with placement breakdown and potential placement breakdown in the future.A subsample of 280 cases was used.Logistic regressions indicated that in agreement with the hypothesis, each additional year of child age is correlated with a 19.0%(95% CI [1.050, 1.347]) increase in odds of actual placement breakdown and a 10.3% (95% CI [1.022, 1.190]) increase in odds of potential placement breakdown.It was also found that, in disagreement with the hypothesis, for children who had one biological parent with legal parental rights, the odds of potential placement breakdown (i.e., the unwillingness of foster caregivers to continue caring for children long-term) were 0.253 times (95% CI [0.114, 0.559]) that of children who had no biological parents with legal parental rights.No other significant relationships were found, indicating that rational choice theory applied to these data cannot fully explain why placement breakdown occurs.Keywords: foster placement breakdown, rational choice being utilized to build a framework for social exchange (where individuals use a cost-benefit analysis to determine potential risks and benefits in relationships with others; Homans, 1958) and later formalized into a bona fide theory (Coleman, 1994).It posits that individuals are rational actors motivated by self-interests (Hechter & Kanazawa, 1997).Rewards benefit the actor's selfinterests, and costs harm the actor's self-interests.Under rational choice theory, individuals make decisions that offer the greatest reward-to-cost ratio.Actors weigh rewards and costs by comparing their options in two different ways: expectations, or comparison between the actor and peers in similar situations (i.e., comparison level), and comparison between the actor and peers in a situation in which the actor could find themselves if they choose one of the options available to them (i.e., comparison of alternatives; Hechter & Kanazawa, 1997).In both scenarios (comparison level and comparison level of alternatives), actors rationally seek to make choices that advance their self-interests.Rational choice theory will inform the selection of foster child, foster parent, and case variables for this study as well as help to keep a tight focus on foster placement breakdown within the larger focus area of placement instability.
Author: Blodgett, Rebecca C.
Institution: University of Maine
Language: English
Topic: Child Welfare and Adoption
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7062281444
