Work

Tackling Deforestation at Subnational Scales in the Brazilian Amazon: Diverse Municipalities, Agents, and the Struggle for Collective Action in a Moving Frontier

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The Brazilian Amazon is a mosaic of social-cultural and environmental realities, urban and \nrural. Home to 28 million people living across hundreds of municipalities, the region has \nbeen the stage for conflicting narratives and demands over conservation and development. \nHow do agents across diverse municipalities respond to national anti-deforestation policies \nin the Amazon? This dissertation examined the development of the Brazilian forest \nlegislation, the trajectory of colonization, territorial occupation, and development of \nAmazonian municipalities, and the implications of one emblematic national antideforestation \npolicy targeting municipalities along the region’s expanding frontier: the List \nof Priority Municipalities (LPM). The LPM policy has imposed tough sanctions on \nmunicipalities considered hotspots of deforestation, being considered innovative for \nrequiring both individual and collective actions to curtail deforestation. This research \nadopted a social-ecological systems’ perspective, drawing upon the Institutional Analysis \nand Development framework to guide systematic data collection, integration, and analysis. \nMixed methods were combined to analyze archival documents, geospatial and official \nsecondary datasets compiled for 530 municipalities in the Amazon biome, and in-depth case \nstudies and interviews with diverse stakeholders. That provided complementary evidence \nto the multi-spatial and temporal analysis of three questions. First, the dissertation drew \nupon archival research and past forest regulations to ask how narratives and values about \nforests have evolved. Second, it compiled official secondary data at the municipal level and \nused logistic regression models to inquiry about the factors and local attributes affecting compliance with the LPM policy. Third, the research combined multivariate analysis and indepth \ncase studies to examine interactions both between the geographical context of listed \nmunicipalities and within the region’s moving frontier, as well as to analyze factors \nunderlying collaboration among local agents. Findings show that forest legislation and \nnarratives about the value of forests have expanded in scope, resulting in more stringent and \ncomprehensive regulations. However, interest groups have recurrently contested the \nsocietal value of forests, undermining forest regulations that threaten sectoral activities. \nFurther, results revealed that historical-geographical factors defined municipal attributes \nand conditions across the moving frontier that have either facilitated or hindered local \nresponses to LPM sanctions. The location of municipalities in areas undergoing different \nphases of occupation and transformation significantly affected the ability of local agents and \nmunicipal governments to comply with policy criteria applied similarly across the region. \nThe analysis highlights the importance of strengthening law enforcement and municipal \nenvironmental governance, and the relevance of inter-institutional cooperation among \ngovernments, markets, and civil organizations. The study shows both challenges and \nopportunities for balancing regional development and forest conservation through \ncollaboration among diverse groups of agents and levels of governance.
Institution: Indiana University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7062357612
Cites: 155
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10