Within-species Variation in Cognition in Cichlid Fishes: Influences of Social Status and Personality
Year: 2018
Type: article
Abstract: Cognition, the processes involved in acquiring, storing, and the use of information from the environment, plays a critical role in the presentation of behavior.Cognition may influence the perception of risk, the success in which an individual obtains mating opportunities, or how an individual navigates through a complex habitat.While there are benefits to having some cognitive abilities, there is also variation within a species for many of these abilities.Differences in social status and behavioral type between individuals may drive the variation we observe in cognitive abilities.For my dissertation, I examine this main question: How does individual variation in status and personality influence cognition?Specifically, I investigate how 1) dominance hierarchies influence the ability to recognize individuals, 2) dominance hierarchies influence use of socially acquired information, and 3) personality influences the rate of associative learning.I use an experimental approach using two Lake Tanganyikan fish species, Neolamprologus pulcher and Julidochromis ornatus.Both are species that live in long term groups with dominance hierarchies.In Chapter 2, I examine if mid-ranking individuals can recognize multiple individuals, and if they prioritize who they can individually identify based on potential fitness benefits.Using live and animated stimuli of N. pulcher, I found that midranking individuals can discriminate between familiar and unfamiliar individuals.Even more, they can distinguish high-ranking (dominant) familiar and unfamiliar fish as well iii as lower-ranking individuals.These results suggest that individuals benefit from recognizing multiple members of their group.In Chapter 3, I hypothesized that observers would use social information from individuals that would increase their fitness.Specifically, I predicted that observers would use information from demonstrators more dominant (which in N. pulcher are older and larger) than themselves.I tested this is N. pulcher and I found that observers used social information from females that were larger than themselves, suggesting that social status does influence the use of social information.This could be either because they pay more attention to these individuals or because these individuals have been successful at foraging and avoiding predators In Chapter 4, I tested the hypothesis that an interaction between personality and type of association task influences an individual's learning rate.Specifically, I predicted that highly aggressive and exploratory individuals would learn novel associations quickly and reversal associations more slowly, compared to less aggressive and exploratory individuals.I tested this hypothesis with two food-location association tasks in J. ornatus.I did not find that personality was associated with learning rate, thus failing to support my hypothesis.However, I did find that social environment (whether individuals had a mate) influenced learning task completion and environmental temperature influences learning rate.In an environment where food is limited, this suggests that motivation for a food reward influences learning.As a whole, this work suggests that the variation in an individual's social environment does influence cognitive abilities, but I did not find evidence that variation in an individual's personality influences the cognitive abilities that I explored.truly an outstanding mentor and I am grateful his patience, guidance, and support.I would also like to thank Libby Marschall, for she, along with Ian, invested a great amount of time teaching me how science works and how to be a scientist.I would like to thank my committee, Andy Roberts, Suzanne Gray, and Dawn Kitchen for their mentorship as well as their thoughtful contributions to this project.I owe thanks to Stu Ludsin and the other members of the AEL for allowing me to take over one of their fish rooms for a summer, as well as for their guidance on the Julies
Author: Hoskins, Elizabeth Anne, Hoskins
Institution: The Ohio State University
Language: English
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7062584503
