Work

Work and School in the Transition to Adulthood: Implications for Objective and Subjective Career Outcomes Across Individuals from Diverse Backgrounds

Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: College is a key piece of the career pathways taken by many young adults today.However, college education is not a homogenous experience and varies in meaningful ways including the occurrence and timing of entry, type, and degree receipt.Moreover, many youth bypass college altogether and instead directly transition into the job market.Yet education and work after high school have commonly been examined as separate domains, often measured as binary transitions.Moreover, research on career development during the transition to adulthood has tended to ignore the contribution of employment.My research centers on providing a more comprehensive approach in understanding young adults' early career development by modeling career transitions that encompass diverse postsecondary education and work experiences, which may occur both with and without each other.I use National Longitudinal Study of Youth 1997 (NLSY97), a longitudinal nationally representative dataset to identify young adults' career pathways and further explore the contextual factors that shape them and their links to subjective and objective career outcomes.Chapter 1 introduces my motivation for studying young adults' work and school trajectories, the life course theory as an overarching theoretical framework of these studies, and the NLSY97 used as the main dataset in all three studies.In Chapter 2, latent class analyses were conducted to identify the common career trajectories among young adults based on multiple work and school transition characteristics beginning from the timeline of their expected high ii school graduation until about eight years after.The role of family socioeconomic status (SES), individuals' future expectations, and local labor market conditions in predicting work and school pathways were also examined.This study identified four work and school pathways associated with a) pursuing a Bachelor's degree b) pursuing an Associate's degree c) entering the workforce with a high school diploma and d) showing limited engagement in both postsecondary education and early work.I also found that parental socioeconomic status and individuals' future expectations were associated with work and school pathways, whereas local labor market conditions were not.The aim of Chapter 3 was to examine how the work and school pathways identified in Chapter 2 were associated with their future subjective and objective career outcomes, and whether these associations vary by gender and SES.The findings suggest that the pathways were significantly associated with objective labor market outcomes but had limited relations with subjective career outcomes.However, the associations between work and school pathways and future job satisfaction varied by gender and SES.In Chapter 4, I used propensity score matching to estimate the career returns to different postsecondary educational experiences (e.g., Bachelor's degree receipt, Associate's degree receipt, some college experience, never enrolled in college) and further investigate whether the career returns vary by gender and SES.The findings indicate similar patterns to Chapter 3, in which postsecondary educational attainment levels significantly predicted objective labor market outcomes and had very little associations with job satisfaction.However, there were nuanced differences in the role of postsecondary educational attainment on job satisfaction across gender and SES.Lastly, Chapter 5 provides general contributions, integration of the findings, and limitations/strengths of the introduced studies as well as future directions.iii Acknowledgments First and foremost, I would like to thank every person in the OSU and community who helped me complete this dissertation during a worldwide crisis we will never forget in our lives.I sincerely am grateful to have been around such wonderful people who encouraged and supported me while we were all going through this difficult time together.This accomplishment would not have been possible without my advisor Kelly Purtell's guidance throughout all my years in graduate school.Kelly, you were always compassionate and patient, while also pushing me to think harder, work more rigorously, and strive to make more meaningful work for the people whom I hope to improve lives of.I will always remember your impact in my life that made me become who I am as a person and scholar.I would also like to express my gratitude to the committee members, who have trained me over my entire graduate school experience and dissertation process to improve my scholarly work as a graduate student.Dr. Anastasia Snyder was one of the initial mentors who taught me how to use secondary datasets, weigh the pros and cons, and make compromises in order to conduct meaningful analyses despite the statistical and data-related limitations.She also critically influenced me to contemplate the scholarly and societal implications of my findings, and how my work can change individuals' lives in a meaningful way.Dr. Michael Betz introduced me to the world of economical and sociological analyses, and pushed me to think about why I am using certain variables, datasets, and statistical methods to address the core research questions that I aim to examine.Dr. Jessica Logan was a pivotal influence for me to decide the population and measure of my interest, given that I had to make critical decisions based on the limitations in the iv dataset and statistical methods I used.I am also grateful for her substantive role in teaching me how to conduct latent class analyses, the foundational method used in two of my three studies.Lastly, I would like to thank my mentor at Education Testing Service, Dr. Margarita Olivera-Aguilar, who trained me to be more rigorous, accurate, and to challenge myself with novel ways of solving the same question using different statistical approaches.Your mentorship inspired me to think about what a good mentor is and motivated me to strive to become one myself in the future when the appropriate time comes.I also thank my mother, father, and little brother for being there for me and continued to emotionally and wholeheartedly support my decision to pursue a PhD abroad.I know you all have been worried about me but are also proud of me.I thank you for sending me care packages to make sure I take care of myself to get through all this.I am also grateful to have such a wonderful mother-in-law and father-in-law who spent their time listening to my practice talks and constantly made me believe I am smart and talented and that I can make it through graduate school.You helped me build confidence when I needed it the most.I would like to give a special thanks to my sister, Eugene, who will be another future Dr. Cho in our family soon.I won't say much as it will be impossible to describe all of the things we went through together and how much help you have given me throughout my entire life.Words cannot describe my gratitude and love for you, but I will say I thank you and love you with all my heart.You have been giving me the best constructive criticisms for my work.Without you, I will not be the person I am now, and I am very, very, very proud of the person you are now.Lastly, I thank my husband, Brian Baker, my joy and rock.
Author: Cho, Sugene
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7062853398
FWCI: 0.226
Cites: 80
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10