Work

Budsjettet og alternative styringsverktøy – venner eller fiender? En SEM-analyse av betingelsesfaktorer, bruk av styringsverktøy, og deres påvirkning på opplevd prestasjon

Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Since the post-war period, the budget has played an important role in the management accounting of organizations but has recently been the subject of extensive criticism. However, the critics disagree with the solution to these problems. While the most radical critics believe that the budget must be rejected in its entirety and that alternative management accounting systems (MAS) need to be implemented, the more conservatives believe the budget should be complemented with alternative MAS. Previous studies show that, despite the extensive criticism, the budget is still extensively used (Libby & Lindsay 2010; Ekholm & Wallin 2000; Johanson & Madsen, 2013), while alternative MAS are used to some extent (Bjørnenak, 2013). Furthermore, previous research has studied the use of MAS in relation to contingency factors, such as external factors and organizational factors, and performance (Chenhall, 2003). Bjørnenak (2013) linked the use of MAS to profitability, where he found that the budget had a negative correlation with return on equity, while some of the alternative MAS had a positive correlation. This study will address the following research question: "In what way does contingency factors affect perceived performance, where the use of management tools has a mediating role?" In order to answer this research question, a quantitative study has been conducted, where a total of 420 financial managers participated. The data was collected through a survey and further analyzed using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The results of the research model are discussed on the basis of contingency theory and previous research. The findings of this study indicate that the budget is still extensively used, while alternative MAS are used to a moderate extent. The findings also indicate that the contingency factors perceived environmental hostility, structure, size, and functionality of the information system affect the use of MAS. In addition, it appears that the use of budgets has a negative impact on perceived performance, while the use of alternative MAS has a positive impact. Furthermore, the use of budgets and alternative MAS is positively correlated, which indicates that when one uses the budget to a greater extent, alternative MAS are also used to a greater extent. This is interesting as it contradicts the most radical budget critics, who believe alternative MAS should replace budgets in their entirety.
Authors: Renate Helen Nordheim, Heidi Lan Skog
Language: Norwegian Bokmål
Subfield: Accounting
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7064660769
Cites: 79
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10