Does growth require suffering? Positive personality changes following major life events with high emotional valence
Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: “What doesn’t kill us makes us stronger.” This famous notion of the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche emphasizes a deep conviction concerning the development of human nature (Joseph, 2011). It highlights the idea that our worst experiences in life might have a silver lining and - after the initial suffering they cause - result in long-term benefits. The phenomenon, that potentially traumatic life events can result in personal growth, has gained broad scientific attention in the last few years. Tedeschi and Calhoun (2004) described the term posttraumatic growth as beneficial psychological changes that occur as a result of struggling with highly challenging life situations. Going further, the pioneering work of Roepke (2013) has suggested that not only our worst, but also our best experiences might result in personal growth. While posttraumatic growth has been extensively studied in previous research, growth after positive experiences has rarely ever been addressed in existing literature. Thus, one critical question has not been answered: Does growth require suffering? In spite of the growing number of publications, a lot of previous research has suffered from severe methodological shortcomings. First, most studies focused exclusively on negative events as possible catalysts for growth and neglected the possibility of personality changes following positive experiences. Additionally, the question of specific mechanisms that lead to personal growth has rarely been addressed in previous publications (Park & Helgeson, 2006). Finally, most studies relied on the retrospective self-perception of change, instead of using external indicators or longitudinal data, as suggested by leading experts in the field (Jayawickreme & Blackie, 2016). This dissertation has aimed to address these shortcomings and contribute to the scientific body investigating growth following life’s best and worst experiences. The goal of Study 1 was to estimate the impact of a broad array of life events in a cross- cultural design, in order to quantify the experience of major life events and to compare the influence of positive and negative experiences. Participants from the USA (n = 555) and India (n = 599) were provided with a revised version of the Social Readjustment Rating Scale (Holmes & Rahe, 1967). The results indicate that US American participants perceived negative events as more impactful, while Indian participants rated events with positive valence as more important. Study 1 showed that the negativity bias and the belief that negative events have a greater impact on our lives (Baumeister, Bratslavsky, Finkenauer, & Vohs; 2001) are not universal, but in part a cultural artifact. Study 2 aimed to identify general key factors which promote posttraumatic and postecstatic growth. Based on previous research, I suggested a process model that includes three factors facilitating personal growth after positive and negative events, namely meaning-making, supportive relationships, and positive emotions. The results of US American (n = 342) and Indian (n = 341) participants indicated that posttraumatic and postecstatic growth are highly interrelated and that the model predicts growth after positive, as well as negative, experiences across countries. Study 3 was a longitudinal MRI study with the goal of identifying structural neural correlates of coping strategies that are likely to contribute to personal growth. We recruited pregnant women and followed them through pregnancy and the first months of parenthood. Before childbirth, women answered questions about their proactive coping behavior, measured with the Personal Growth Initiative Scale (PGIS-II; Robitschek et al., 2012). One month and then four months after delivery, structural brain data were acquired. For N = 22 women, postpartal MRI data were available. Prenatal PGI levels were correlated with gray matter volume after birth through voxel-based morphometry. Personal growth initiative before childbirth was positively associated with postpartal gray matter volume in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, a brain region that shows reductions in participants suffering from posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Study 4. Most research on posttraumatic growth is based on cross-sectional data. This circumstance has been identified as one of the most critical aspects of previous research (Frazier et al., 2009; Jayawickreme & Blackie, 2014; 2016). In order to investigate actual benefits of positive and negative life events, we conducted Study 4, a large-scale meta-analysis based on longitudinal studies, including 364 effect sizes. The results indicate that genuine personal growth exists in the areas of self-esteem, social relationships, and environmental mastery. The findings show that genuine growth can occur as a result of positive as well as negative events. In summary, people can grow as much from life’s best as from its worst experiences. The notion that “bad is stronger than good” (Baumeister et al., 2001) is rather a cultural bias than a universal truth. Factors such as meaning-making, supportive relationships, positive emotions, and proactive coping are more critical for growth than the valence of the event encountered. This dissertation showed that suffering is a possible, but not necessary, prerequisite for personal growth.
Author: Mangelsdorf, Judith
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2771918047
