Work

Learning from worked-out examples: Multiple representations, an integration help, and self-explanation prompts all foster understanding

Year: 2006
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Multiple representations (e.g., an equation and a diagram) are commonly used because they can provide unique benefits when learners are trying to gain a deep understanding (Ainsworth, in press). Regrettably, many studies have shown that this promise is not always achieved. Often, learners are overwhelmed with the complex demands of integrating and understanding multiple representations. This suggests that learners might profit from learning with multiple representations to a larger extent when instructional support measures on integrating and understanding are employed. Therefore, the main goal of this dissertation is to experimentally investigate the effects of multiple representations and two corresponding instructional support measures on learning processes (i.e., self-explanations) and learning outcomes (i.e., conceptual and procedural knowledge). Do students learn more deeply from multiple representations than from one representation alone? Do instructional support measures such as an integration help in form of flashing and color-coding as well as self-explanation prompts further enhance the benefits of multiple representations? What are the crucial processes with this respect? These questions are the focus of this dissertation. To address these questions, two experiments were conducted in which we employed worked-out examples from the domain of probability theory and tested the effects of multiple representations, an integration help in form of a flashing-color-coding procedure, and self-explanation prompts. In Experiment 1, the effects of two types of self-explanation prompts (scaffolding vs. open) as help procedures for integrating and understanding multiple representations were analyzed. Experiment 2 additionally tested the effects of multi- vs. mono-representational solutions and an integration help. The findings of Experiment 1 were taken up insofar in Experiment 2 as we implemented scaffolding self-explanation prompts which proved to be effective in Experiment 1. Overall, results showed that multiple representations embedded in worked-out examples and an integration help fostered conceptual knowledge. With respect to procedural knowledge, it was equally effective to provide multi- or mono-representational solutions or presenting the multi-representational solutions with or without an integration help. Self-explanation prompts fostered high-quality self-explanations and conceptual knowledge. With respect to conceptual knowledge, scaffolding self-explanation prompts were especially effective when compared to open prompts (scaffolding self-explanation effect). Though, scaffolding self-explanation prompts also evoked incorrect self-explanations that impaired the acquisition of procedural knowledge (paradox self-explanation prompt effect). Chapter 1 provides the general theoretical background for this dissertation involving a disambiguation as well as information about the learning approach and the domain of this research. In chapter 2, the computer-based learning environment which was developed for this research is described. Chapter 3 provides an overview of the two experiments of this dissertation and the main research questions are elaborated. In chapter 4 and 5, the two experiments are presented that examined the effects of multiple representations, an integration help, and self-explanation prompts. These chapters include a theoretical introduction addressing the specific research problem, a presentation of the corresponding research questions, the method and results as well as a discussion of the findings. Chapter 4 on Experiment 1 describes the effects of two types of self-explanation prompts as help procedures for integrating and understanding multiple representations. Chapter 5 on Experiment 2 presents the effects of multi- vs. mono-representational solutions, an integration help in form of a flashing-color-coding procedure, and scaffolding self-explanation prompts. Chapter 6 concludes with an overall discussion of the findings, theoretical and practical implications, limitations as well as an outline of future research directions.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7066986617
Cites: 73
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10