Work

Referendums, deliberatie en de rol van het recht

Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The starting point for this thesis was the debate on the preceived crisis of representative democracy, and the place of referendums within this debate. While certain authors see referendums as a means to rejuvenate democracy, other authors perceive them as a threat to representative democracy. In light of these contrasting perspectives, I decided to evaluate referendums through the lens of deliberative democracy, with a particular focus on what role the law could play to make the referendum process more deliberative. In this thesis, I argue that referendums can make a positive contribution to democracy under specific conditions. Firstly, I emphasised that referendums cannot go at it alone but can only be expected to play a specific and limited role, and necessarily have to rely on other institutions to manage the communicative abundance in the public sphere, to filter inputs, and to formulate proposals. Secondly, I argued for the necessity of an inclusive deliberative process preceding a referendum vote, ensuring equal participation and fair consideration of diverse societal perspectives. Thirdly, I stressed the importance of citizens not just having opportunities to speak but also the capacity to comprehend the various claims being made during a referendum campaign, in order for a referendum vote to be considered legitimate. Building on existing work in the field of deliberative democracy, I then developed a number of criteria by which the deliberative quality of referendum campaigns can be assessed. I argued against transposing the requirements of an idealised form of deliberation as face-to-face dialogue to the referendum campaign. Instead, I argued that the asymmetry between speaker and audience which characterises referendum campaigns is compatible with the demands of deliberative democracy as long as voters can see themselves and their perspectives represented in the public debate. In this way, referendums cannot escape the need for representation any more than "purely" representative democracies. I then examined the prevalent approaches to referendum campaign regulation, through a number of case studies. I critiqued both the 'maximum freedoms' and 'regulated equality' models, revealing their blind spots when viewed from the perspective of deliberative democracy. In response, I proposed a deliberative democratic alternative to referendum campaign regulation, which seeks to create connections between the referendum debate and parliamentary proceedings, to provide more speech opportunities for citizens, to hold campaigners accountable for their speech, and to enhance the capacity of citizens to critically asses the various claims that are made during a referendum campaign.
Source: Lirias
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7070933796
Cites: 358
Cited by:
Related to: 10