Year: 1984
Type: article
Abstract: This timely, ambitious book is already highly acclaimed.Although scholarly in style, it has touched the exposed nerve endings of enough readers to ensure its place as a provocative-and importantcontribution to the field, and to thoughtful nonfiction in general.Author Starr, a young sociologist at Harvard, has added an eclectic mix of social history, political science, and journalism, although an essentially sociological perspective does dominate the result.While it has been suggested that this volume represents a comprehensive history of the American medical care system, in fact its focus is somewhat narrower.Starr's subtitle, "The Rise of a Sovereign Profes- sion and the Making of a Vast Industry," helps identify the two rela- tively separate concerns that divide his work into what amounts to two separate books.The first focuses on the American medical profession, summarizing how by the early years of this century it had succeeded in making itself sovereign.The transformation he highlights traces the evolution of social position and professional power that epitomizes the physician.Starr infuses a sense of drama into his account of how a frail and insecure profession, viewed by the public with skepticism if not mistrust, was able to generate enough faith in its power to acquire an essentially unprecedented "cultural authority."This acquisition of authority, Starr shows, enabled physicians to establish themselves as a united and prosperous profession; it also ensured their ability to exer- cise nearly undisputed control over all matters related to health.Not only did the terms and conditions of their own work come under their purview but so did that of hospitals and all other health-related institu- tions.The ground that Starr covers in this "first book" is likely to be relatively unfamiliar to most of his readers; however, few can be expected to take exception to its basic thrust.The second book embedded within this one volume is entitled, "The Struggle for Medical Care: Doctors, the State, and the Coming of the Corporation."It deals with developments far less remote in time and about which much more has been written.Accordingly, many will probably respond to it in a far more critical and emotional fashion.
Source: PubMed Central
Author: Seipp, Conrad
Language: English
Topic: Health, Medicine and Society
Subfield: General Health Professions
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7071605062
