Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In an ideal scenario, innovation policy leads to optimal societal outcomes by allowing the market forces to determine technology choices according to the principle of technological neutrality. However, criticism of technological neutrality has increased since 2000s as the market-oriented innovation policies have failed to address major societal challenges. This study contributes to this debate by examining the implications of the principle of technological neutrality for the effective design of transformative innovation policy mixes. The general research design of this study emphasises the approach of theory elaboration and abduction while including some traits of theory generation and induction. The empirical part of this study is conducted as an embedded single case study to analyse the role of technological neutrality in the Finnish innovation system. The final sample is a unique combination of 32 interviews, including a broad range of actors in the Finnish innovation system, and all 55 Finnish parliamentary discussions in 2014 – 2023 where technological neutrality was discussed. The data was analysed by following the principles of reflexive thematic analysis to identify and develop themes from the data. Finally, the empirical results were integrated into the theory-based models which were developed as part of the literature review. The main findings of this study are twofold. First, this study suggests that technological neutrality impacts innovation policy outcomes through three intermediate policy goals: (1) fairness, (2) technological goals, and (3) policy sustainability. The policy makers should pursue the desired goals by customising the policy design related to technological neutrality with different governance arrangements, policy goal boundary setting, and five different techniques to operationalise technological neutrality. Both technology neutral and specific policies can be justified depending on the desired goal and various contextual factors. Second, this study proposes a process for designing policy mixes from the perspective of technological neutrality by connecting the implications of technological neutrality into broader policy mix context. In conclusion, this study recommends taking a pragmatic approach to applying technological neutrality in policy design.
Source: Aaltodoc (Aalto University)
Author: Carpen, Juho
Language: English
Topic: Innovation Policy and R&D
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7071849139
