Substantive or Symbolic Compliance with Mandatory Sustainability Reporting? : Evidence from the European Union’s Non-Financial Reporting Directive
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis studies mandatory sustainability reporting by analysing corporate behaviour through two novel approaches: greenwashing, measured by the disclosure-performance gap, and cost behaviour, assessed via cost stickiness. Drawing primarily on institutional theory and supported by complementary theoretical perspectives, the thesis proposes and empirically tests competing hypotheses to distinguish substantive from symbolic compliance with regulation. Employing the difference-in-differences estimation, the analysis compares companies from 17 European Union (EU) countries subject to the European Union’s Non-Financial Reporting Directive 2014/95/EU against companies from 11 non-EU OECD countries. The studied period spans around the implementation of the directive in 2017, delineated into pre-implementation (2013–2016) and post-implementation (2017–2022) phases. To mitigate endogeneity concerns and strengthen causal inference, the study incorporates a range of methodological strategies, including parallel trend analysis, propensity score matching, multiple model specifications, and a robust set of control variables. Results show a significant widening of the disclosure-performance gap among the EU companies post-implementation of the directive, indicating symbolic compliance. Conversely, a notable increase in cost stickiness among these companies suggests genuine organizational change, especially pronounced in companies with improved sustainability performance. The thesis offers a theoretical contribution by conceptualizing and empirically substantiating the disclosure-performance gap and cost stickiness as analytical constructs in the context of mandatory sustainability reporting. Moreover, its cross-country and longitudinal research design addresses prevalent gaps in the literature. Practically, it offers policy implications for regulators aiming to design effective sustainability reporting frameworks that encourage authentic sustainability transformations at the organizational level.
Author: Tariq, Ammarah
Institution: Mid Sweden University
Language: English
Subfield: Strategy and Management
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7080187147
