Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This doctoral dissertation explores the emergence of quantum computing, a new field of science, technology, and business. My dissertation sheds light on future-oriented organizing in field and market emergence by employing three lenses: linguistic, temporal and material. The research provides valuable insights into the social-symbolic aspects of field emergence. It also illustrates ventures and other field actors can manage public opinion and shape the nascent field beyond technological development. Quantum computing presents a specific case of deep tech—a category of technologies based on foundational scientific inquiry and characterized by long time-to-market and capital intensiveness. In the case of quantum computing, the ultimate goal of the field, a universal quantum computer is yet to be built. My thesis thus examines how a field emerges around a novel technology that itself is still emerging. This dissertation comprises an introduction and three essays. The introduction provides a review of liteature on field and market emergence and future-oriented organizing, an overview of the methodology, and a discussion focusing on future-oriented organizing in emerging settings. The first essay examines the linguistic tools of sensemaking by focusing on the visual and verbal sensemaking of quantum computing as a de novo market category. In this paper, we examine how actors use metaphors, analogies, and other linguistic devices to construct a novel market category. Through a multimodal analysis of text and visuals, we show how cultural entrepreneurs use different types of tropes not only to legitimate the emerging technology, but also to demarcate it as profoundly different and novel. We introduce the concept of a temporal trope, used specifically to provide a future-oriented understanding of the category. In the second essay I study the case of quantum computing from a future-making perspective. Adopting a Communication as constitutive of organization (CCO) approach, I demonstrate how quantum computing materializes through communicative acts by central stakeholders, and how different degrees of materialization shape the hypotheticality and temporal distance of the future. The main contribution of this essay is to the nascent research stream on future-making, highlighting the role that materiality, even when absent or symbolic, plays in field-level future-making processes. The third essay sheds light on how consultants create a market for knowledge in a novel field by engaging in temporal work. This essay contributes to the literatures of temporal work and market intermediaries by showing how management consultants engage in temporal work to construct a market for knowledge in the emerging field. These three perspectives advance our understanding of future-oriented organizing in emerging settings by emphasizing the constitutive and performative role of language in meaning-making and the materialization of futures. What is more, the essays shed light on how actors from different communities make sense of and engage with the uncertain and ambiguous future of quantum computing, using it as an asset rather than a liability.
Source: Aaltodoc (Aalto University)
Author: Hilkamo, Oona
Institution: University of Bath
Language: English
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7081706548
