Work

“Is she the real victim here?” – A Victimological Analysis of Finnish Rape Judgments

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Introduction: In Finland, rates of sexual violence remain high, with women disproportionately affected.In 2023, Finland adopted consent-based rape legislation, following other European countries and responding to criticism of narrow interpretations of rape victims' experiences and low conviction rates.Against this background, this thesis examines Finnish District Court rape judgments from 2021-2022, analysing how victim-complainants are described and assessed prior to the legal reform.It further explores the appearance of rape myths and gender stereotypes in rape judgments and their influence on case outcomes.Methods: This study analyses 27 Finnish District Court rape judgments from 2021-2022, collected through a District Court archive request.Only cases involving adult female victims and adult male defendants were included.The data was examined using Thematic Analysis with a deductive orientation, guided by the Stereotype Content Model.Results: The results showed that victim-complainants who were perceived as either warm, competent, or both, were recognized as rape victims.A high level in at least one of these dimensions strengthened the court's view of the victim-complainant as credible.Based on the analysis, victim-complainants could be divided into five distinct categories.Each category reflected different combinations of perceived warmth and competence, illustrating how these dimensions shaped the courts' evaluation of credibility.Conclusion: The outcomes of the judgments were influenced by subjective and stereotypical expectations regarding how rape victims should behave and express themselves.The credibility of a victim-complainant was linked to their perceived warmth and/or competence, with deviations from expected behaviour and lack of emotional expression supporting acquittals.The results indicate that if legal decision-makers' understanding of the situational factors surrounding sexual violence, the diversity of victim reactions, or the strategies used by rape victims to navigate threatening situations do not improve, the goal set by the new law of enhancing sexual self-determination and access to justice is unlikely to be achieved.
Institution: Malmö University
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7082313515
Cites: 41
Cited by:
Related to: 10