Has Aging Become a Disease? The (Bio)medicalization of Aging and Its Effects on Social Representations and Professional Practices
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Over the past forty years, aging—and particularly cognitive aging—has been increasingly subject to processes of (bio)medicalization. Rather than being understood as a natural, heterogeneous, and multidimensional process that encompasses dynamics of growth, maintenance, and decline, aging has gradually been reduced to a medical narrative centered on deterioration and pathology. The transformation of senility into Alzheimer’s disease exemplifies this shift: what was once considered an ordinary stage of old age has become a medical problem requiring urgent treatment in the context of demographic aging. This PhD thesis builds on critical scholarship in medical sociology and gerontology, which highlights the effects of the (bio)medicalization of aging on social representations and professional practices. The aim of this research is to examine the social construction of aging as a medical problem and to better understand the practical repercussions of (bio)medicalization—whether on how older people are perceived, on their environments, or on the development of interventions directed toward them. The first theoretical section provides an in-depth analysis of the mechanisms and effects of (bio)medicalization, four of which were the focus of particular attention through five empirical studies. The first effect concerns perceptions of aging and ageism in society. The dominance of a biomedical model centered on decline tends to stigmatize older adults and reinforce ageism, especially among health professionals whose training often rests on a pathophysiological approach to aging. The first study compared perceptions of older adults between health professionals and the general public, highlighting the stereotypical biases shaped by the medical framework. The second effect is reflected in the medicalization of older people’s environments. The integration of medical devices and equipment transforms living spaces into care settings, with the white coat becoming a symbol of this transformation. Two studies explored this medicalized practice. A narrative review synthesized the effects of wearing a white coat when interacting with older adults, while an experimental study examined how such attire influences public perceptions of older people. These studies demonstrate that the simple act of wearing a white coat can reinforce the relational asymmetry between caregiver and care recipient. The third effect concerns the stigma associated with Alzheimer’s disease. Diagnostic labeling contributes to the formation of negative representations, eliciting stigmatizing emotional and behavioral reactions. One study assessed public perceptions of different diagnostic labels, revealing the ambivalent effects—both protective, sometimes paternalistic, and stigmatizing—of the label “Alzheimer’s disease.” The fourth effect is manifested through the uneven allocation of resources, with priority given to biomedical and pharmacological research at the expense of psychosocial initiatives for people living with dementia and their caregivers. A fifth study assessed the impact of training programs for health professionals on the individualized support of family caregivers, underlining the contribution of non-pharmacological interventions in rebalancing practices. Taken together, these findings show that while the (bio)medicalization of aging offers certain therapeutic, social, and financial benefits, it also tends to confine older adults within stereotyped representations, to structure interactions along hierarchical lines, and to limit the development of alternative forms of support. Critiquing this process does not imply a wholesale rejection of the biomedical approach but rather calls for a rebalancing that integrates biomedical perspectives alongside psychological, social, and environmental ones. This PhD thesis argues for a (partial) demedicalization of aging at both conceptual and practical levels. The development of psychosocial interventions, the inclusion of older adults in research, and the reorganization of institutional environments represent key levers for moving beyond an exclusively medical framework. By promoting a biopsychosocial approach, this work invites a rethinking of the culture of aging beyond biomedical dominance, in order to valorize the plurality of experiences and narratives of later life.
Source: ORBi (University of Liège)
Author: Crutzen, Coline
Institution: University of Liège
Language: English
Subfield: Developmental and Educational Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7082314927
